10 reasons Mac OS X Lion eats Windows for breakfast

Dan Warne
07 September 2011, 12:08 PM


Why the new version of Apple's Mac OS X is still miles ahead of Microsoft's Windows and why you need to make the switch.



You've got to hand it to Microsoft; Windows 7 was a spectacular saving of face after the slow-moving train wreck that was Vista. It's a very good OS. But then, Windows XP was pretty good too. Win 7 is basically XP with a coat of paint and a lot of under-the-hood upgrades to cope with more modern system architecture. On the front-end of the OS Microsoft hasn't done much rethinking of the basics in a decade. Part of this stagnation is because of Microsoft's fear of offending corporate customers — every change has to be oh-soslowly introduced (and Redmond just announced another 1,000 days of support for Windows XP, for Chrissakes!). Apple, on the other hand, has no fear of offending anyone. It regularly pisses people off by taking the "our way or the highway" approach. But this lack of ball-and-chain mentality allows it to make rapid improvements in its software that Microsoft seems incapable of making. Here are the top 10 features of Mac OS X 10.7 "Lion" that demonstrate why Apple is still winning against Windows.

1. AirDrop

Networking has never been something that any OS maker has ever been able to make accessible to the non-techy person. Its reliance on accounts, permissions, share names and firewalls puts it in the realm of 'the IT guy' or the geeky family member. With Lion, transferring files between two Mac users is as easy as both of you going to the 'AirDrop' screen. Apple uses Wi-Fi triangulation technology to calculate the physical position of both computers. If it matches you as being close together, it will allow you to establish a peer-to-peer network with each other, and transfer files directly between the two Macs. The connection is still secure — files can only be sent, rather than a network share being browsable, and the receiver of the files has to agree to receive them.

2. Resume

One of the biggest advantages Macs have over Windows PCs generally is utterly reliable, near-instant suspend and resume. It's hard to really understand how useful this is until you've experienced it. Windows has suspend and resume functionality, but how well it works is heavily reliant on the assortment of drivers and how well a system maker has implemented everything. Sadly, the majority of PC makers do not do it right, and Windows can still take several seconds — or longer — to resume. Lion is now taking that to the next level with Resume, which opens apps to the same state they were in when they were last quit. So, if you have to reboot your machine, you can get back to where you were quickly.

3. Auto Save

While Microsoft Office has a good autosave feature, most apps still don't have it. In Lion, Apple has made Auto Save a system-wide API that any app can hook into, meaning everything from the plain text editor upwards will be able to auto-save documents. Because it's built into the OS, it's designed so users and developers don't have to worry about overwriting a good version of a file with a partially edited one — the system keeps multiple duplicate versions. This is married up to an upgraded version of Apple's Time Machine backup software which used to only work when an external or networked hard drive was connected. Now, Time Machine is capable of letting users delve back into previous auto-saved versions. You can even grab pieces out of an older version, rather than restoring a file to a whole version.

4. Virtual desktops

Windows doesn't have them at all, but to be fair to Microsoft, desktop switching isn't exactly something that people have been crying out for. Mac OS X already had 'Spaces' for the last two versions of the OS but it was an unloved feature, ignored by most people, because it was pretty inconvenient to use. In Lion, Spaces is actually useful, due to one key improvement — the ability to swipe between desktops using a multi-touch gesture. There's absolutely no delay; just a silky smooth horizontal scroll.

5. Better app switching


We thought Apple's Exposé window management feature was pretty revolutionary when it was introduced back in 2003 (especially compared to what was available at the time: [Alt]+[Tab] in Windows!) You could press one button on the keyboard and see a shrunken version of all your open windows at once — or just the open windows from your current app. The downside of this was that as Macs got more powerful, people left more and more windows open, and it became difficult to make out which window belonged to what. The new Mission Control feature in Lion is a refined version of Exposé — it shows a miniaturised version of all your apps, along with their windows clustered together, so it's easy to switch apps and switch windows. You can also drag an app to one of your Spaces.


6. iCloud

Sync between computers and mobile devices is still a roadblock for a lot of people. Dropbox has made PC-to-PC sync easy, but because mobile phones are pretty locked down, the Dropbox mobile app doesn't integrate very deeply with the contents of mobile phones. There's Google Sync, but it still requires pages and pages of instructions on how to set it up — and support on the desktop is patchy. Apple's own MobileMe service was an overpriced disaster from day one. The introduction of the free Apple iCloud service will closely sync the iPhone/iPod/iPad with Macs (including Mac-to-Mac sync). One username and password login will do the lot: photos you take on your iPhone will automatically appear on your Mac; documents will sync, apps and music/video content will appear across all the devices, and contacts/mail/calendar will be kept in sync. In OS X Lion, a Mac can even be woken from sleep overnight to do iCloud sync tasks, without having to turn on the monitor or attached USB devices.

7. Remote wipe

In the era of identity theft, notebook users take a big risk by leaving the contents of their notebook open to someone who finds/steals it. Apple's new full-disk encryption in Lion means two things: someone who gets hold of a Mac can only use it if they're already logged in to a user's account. Even if they take the hard drive out, it will be unreadable. But where Lion really beats Windows (which already has full-disk encryption) is that a Mac's hard drive can be remotely erased by its owner. Using iCloud, you can just log in and request that the encryption keys of that Mac be wiped. The instant a crook connects the notebook to a network, the data on that Mac will go up in a puff of encrypted smoke.

8. App store

This will surely come to Windows in Windows 8 — and to an advanced user an app store might not be a big deal — but the popularity of app stores in the mobile space demonstrates how the software discovery and installation process is still a challenge for most people. The app store on Mac OS X makes it possible to buy software using iTunes store credit (or credit card details), and makes it easy for people to find the sort of software they're looking for in a consistent directory format. The little-known killer-feature of the Mac App Store, though: all software purchased through it can be installed on up to 10 Macs! There are also no serial numbers — if you switch Macs or need to reinstall an app later, a list of all previously purchased/downloaded apps is available for one-click reinstallation.

9. Price

Windows 7 Home Premium upgrade costs US$119.99  per PC ($199 per PC in Australia) and the full version costs US$199.99 ($299 in Aus). Meanwhile, Lion costs U$29.99 ($31.99 in Aus) and can be installed on up to 10 Macs. No further explanation required.

10. Sign documents

From the 'tiny feature, but oh so useful' department. You know the promise of the 'paperless office'? Yeah, the faceless bureaucrat who still makes forms that still need to be signed with a pen-and-ink signature didn't seem to get that memo. Apple has found a solution to that. Open up any PDF form in Apple Preview; 'sign' it by stamping your signature on it and saving it again. The brilliant part is how you add your signature to Preview the first time — just sign on a piece of paper and hold it up to the Mac's webcam.



Read more stories about

Post your comment



First 50 Comments

View All Comments (84) RSS feed Email alert

techdribble (User):

I have no reason to switch and there is nothing on this list that is compelling to me.

07 September 2011, 2:18 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

AnthonyBrisbane (New user):

And there are 500 reasons why Windows eats Mac OS X for breakfast

07 September 2011, 2:34 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

petert (Advanced Forumologist):

Here is a free pair of blinkers - just in case your others wear out :-)

07 September 2011, 3:21 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

teslaboy (New user):

The good thing about the blinkers is that they are mutually usable (and from what is regularly seen in the blogosphere, badly needed on both sides).

07 September 2011, 3:52 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

petert (Advanced Forumologist):

Quoting teslaboy:
The good thing about the blinkers is that they are mutually usable (and from what is regularly seen in the blogosphere, badly needed on both sides).


Totally agree with you! I really wonder about people who become so hell-bent about their belief in one OS or another. Are they the same about cars, tvs, shoes, breakfast cereals and everything else in life? What a horrible way to live a life! :-)

07 September 2011, 4:00 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Your Average Joe (User):

Quoting petert:
(and from what is regularly seen in the blogosphere, badly needed on both sides).

I think you and petert have missed the intent of these articles (and I'm not just referring to APC here). Everytime there is an article where it is claimed Windows is either in trouble or dead from Mac or Linux, there are loads of comments. That's how APC and Co. gauge how many users are visiting their sites.

Notice the other articles barely raise 2 or 3 comments, but when Win or OSX is attacked there are plenty to defend the 2 giants. And to a certain extent Linux.





07 September 2011, 8:00 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

petert (Advanced Forumologist):

I read quite a few on-line tech mags every day. It does not matter which OS is under discussion, there is always a horde posters that write a diatribe about that OS. And another horde of posters who expound the virtues of that OS as being manna from Heaven. It is as banal and childish as life can be . . .

08 September 2011, 8:17 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

MichaelN (User):

I agree, Anthony. As an engineer, NOT ONE of the engineering tools I regularly use is compatible with Mac OS. As well as being massively overpriced, a Mac would be completely useless to me - unless I installed Windows on it...

08 September 2011, 12:16 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

coreyw (New user):

"5. Better app switching". Better than what? Dos? OS X's window management tools are hopeless. Once you have more than a few windows open it becomes a nightmare. So they invented Exposé. But it was still a nightmare. So they invented Spaces. But still wasn't too great. So now they have Mission Control. If they had a taskbar-like system instead of the dock, which allows you to switch windows rather than programs they wouldn't have needed all this nonsense.

The only compelling reason is the price. But I guess thats just because nobody would pay the price of Windows for Mac OS X.

07 September 2011, 4:30 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

KevinP (User):

Forget the Windows vs Mac thing - what annoys me is the difference in price of Windows between the US and Australia. While the Mac OS X prices are virtually identical, Microsoft slugs Australian users far more for Windows than it does US users. It is any wonder Australians are rebelling against local vendors and increasingly buying from overseas?

07 September 2011, 5:16 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

huggy55 (New user):

Why buy either one when you can download them for free at www.kat.ph?

16 July 2012, 12:51 PM (10 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

bobneedsawalk (New user):

yeah but who actually buys windows ultimate???
7hp oem is <$100 aud, countered with the cheaper hardware to run it on, it wins.

osx is cheap, but you have to pay for the hardware too. i buy windows, i don;t have to pay everytime a service pack comes out. crap, compare $30 per release to say windows xp, thats 3 major OS revisions, for one price.

windows works better for multitaskers. application and file managment is alot better imho.
a taskbar with current open apps is much better than a doc with a little ^ - hold mouse to see open windows (aero),

the instant search box in the start menu, start calc enter, or start firefox enter. launching apps and control panel items with no more than 5 key presses, even obscure or out of the way items.

where the mac is very mouse centric, the windows pc still allows me to keyboard through if i choose.

the fact my $300 pc with windows home premium is 1/2 the price of the cheapest mac mini and upgradable.

if a part fails, i can buy spares from anywhere, not have to take it to an authorised repairer, pay 300$ exchange for a power supply, plus labour, or render the whole unit worthless.

...... im and im a pc


07 September 2011, 9:56 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Aaron Suzuki (New user):

The expression "virtual desktops" is different here than it is within the broader tech industry where different forms of OS (and application) virtualization allow you to run multiple OSes concurrently. Spaces is really just another desktop UI running from the same OS instance as a means of organizing your work. But regardless of the context, I don’t see people crying for virtual desktops of either sort.

08 September 2011, 9:54 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Aaron Suzuki (New user):

The expression "virtual desktops" is different here than it is within the broader tech industry where different forms of OS (and application) virtualization allow you to run multiple OSes concurrently. Spaces is really just another desktop UI running from the same OS instance as a means of organizing your work. But regardless of the context, I don’t see people crying for virtual desktops of either sort.
The price question is interesting. You pay a premium for a device designed to run OS X, I think it probably should be a cheap upgrade. With Windows you buy a commodity device that could run any of a variety of OSes (but not OS X). It seems like it should cost a more to support and test for all the possible variations. Plus, even with a couple OS upgrades, your hardware plus software cost is still a few pairs of shoes cheaper than a Mac.


08 September 2011, 10:43 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

infra (New user):

Dan warne is nothing but a Troll. He makes useless posts about how good lion is in comparison to windows. What a truly nonobjective comparison and totally biased opinion article.

If you read this Dan you are an idiot for making such stupid antagonising articles. Do something else to get ratings...

08 September 2011, 5:52 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Skip (New user):

Thanks for the laugh Dan.

08 September 2011, 6:04 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JimmyBoyFromOz (User):

Replying to Skip on "Maximise Button"?

Why hasn't windows got a zoom button is a better thing to ask.
Why do you need to maximise a window? If it is to get a better view the zoom button maximises the windows for optimal viewing (font size etc) this is much better since you often have access to other windows or desktop items.
Lion offers full screen view of apps which is the same thing anyway but I would never use this (unless viewing a video for e.g.).
Do people need to see more wasted space left and right of a word document when the document itself is viewing identically.
Running apps full screen (maximised) is being stuck in a rut that made sense back in the days of CGA adaptors and four colours.

11 February 2012, 7:54 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymousewiuu2945u389 (User):

First up, I think you're replying to the wrong user - I brought up the maximise thing, not Skip. But anyway...

Maximise vs. Zoom really is a personal preference thing. I can understand that some people prefer the zoom system. And to be honest, for apps like Notepad, antivirus tools, etc. it does make sense to me to not run them maximised (but then on Snow Leopard, Text Edit's zoom button does maximise ???) Other apps, especially when I'm single-tasking, such as Firefox and Word I prefer maximised so as to hide the desktop (and get a decent view of everything in the ribbon.) The wasted space doesn't bother me as it at least is more colour-co-ordinated than the wallpaper. Plus of course, some apps only make sense maximised - these tend to be the things where Mac OS X's zoom button does maximise the window. If I need multiple windows at once, I use the 'tile vertically' command (or Windows Snap) and adjust the sizes if necessary.

It's all to do with individual user preferences.

11 February 2012, 2:13 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (User):

Quoting JimmyBoyFromOz:
Why do you need to maximise a window?


Simple - to avoid distractions. Sometimes I just can't stay focused on what I'm doing, and maximizing the window helps a lot.

Quoting JimmyBoyFromOz:
Running apps full screen (maximised) is being stuck in a rut that made sense back in the days of CGA adaptors and four colours.


As is idea of having the menu right up the top, not on the window. Yet that still survives.

11 February 2012, 11:01 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymousewiuu2945u389 (User):

Right, let's see...
Intro - the tagline - "Why the new version of Apple's Mac OS X is still miles ahead of Microsoft's Windows" What, because Lion might have gone backwards from Snow Leopard?

1. Never needed to do this
4. This is a solution to a problem that, according to my working style, only exists because of Mac OS X's lack of a maximise button. Not a reason to switch.
5. I love Alt-Tab though, I find it - especially with the thumbnails on Vista and 7 - the most efficient way of switching between apps. To the extent that when I work on a Mac, I use the equivalent Cmd-Tab and Cmd-~ in favour of Expose.
6. The chances of me getting any Apple mobile devices are 0 - so this is a non-issue. And I never use Google Sync, Dropbox etc.
7. Again, something that I can live without. SOme might not be able to, but I can.
8. As a power-user, the App Store dependence of Apple's ecosystem is actually a reason for me to not use a Mac. I don't mind the Linux package manager implementation, but Apple's store stinks of anticompetitive behaviour.
9. For me, Windows is included in the price of a PC. OS X is included in the (often higher) price of a Mac. Anyway, 'you pay less money to upgrade from Snow Leopard to Lion than from Vista to 7' ain't a reason to switch, as the one-off cost of the machine itself has to be taken into consideration i.e. I'd only ever switch when my hardware dies. And Apple seem to be much quicker to kill support for old editions than even Microsoft.
10. Boring.

Now for a much more real reason why Lion is better than Windows - it was released nearly two years later, after the continued rise of smartphones and the (in my opinion unjustified) success of the iPad. The real question is whether or not Windows 8 is one year better than Lion.

As for switching, I still have plenty of reasons to stick with Windows, at least for now - things like application compatability, a maximise button, not needing a new computer, not having to put up with the dock (and associated dead corners of the screen), upgradeable hardware... and future switching will be to Linux, not Mac.

08 September 2011, 6:59 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Andrew Tech Help (New user):

Well we can drop point number 9, that's a misleading point. Yes it costs about $30 for the software, but the hardware you have to buy to run OS X costs about twice as much as a regular PC.

Cheapest Macbook $1099
Average Cost of a decent laptop with Windows Included $400-800

Point 9 GONE!

09 September 2011, 10:09 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

windowsiscool (New user):

ok well, screw this, windows 7 owns this. and when windows 8 is out it's gonna revolutionize the use of computers along with windows 9 delivering the final blow. I mean like who gives a damn about a bunch of useless apps on a system. Maybe a child or an adult of immaturity. ooooo photo booth wow.... windows will always be the better option. and with tablets mac is suing samsung for "ripping off" it's ipad. Apple always gets ticked off when someone makes something better that actually gets better reviews.

09 September 2011, 12:24 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (User):

OK, if parts of this make no sense, it's because I wrote it at work the day the article appeared but didn't have time to post - and I'm too lazy to re-read it now... Here we go...

1: I can see uses for people who meet with lots of random people - IF they all use Macs. Pointless otherwise.
Saying it's secure because you can only send and have to give permission to receive is a bad assumption though. There could be all sorts of ways it could be attacked, especially if it's always enabled - public places could be a minefield. We are talking about the company that installs Bonjour with iTunes without asking...

2: You would have to be a seriously busy person if you couldn't wait an extra 10 seconds for resume. Even if you had to resume 12 times a day, that's a whopping 2 minutes of wasted time per day.

3: This actually sounds kind of interesting and clever. Useful even, since it makes it simple for developers to implement autosave. One less common task for devs to do.

4: Wow. It's only been about 14 years since I started doing that (Litestep on Win95)... And I use it regularly on Linux these days.

5: Looks cluttered to me. Two row task bar seems to work for me in Windows, and on Linux I get away with one because I move windows onto virtual desktops.

6: Coming this Fall (whenever that is). And does this even work if you aren't an Apple Fanboi? I can't see any answer either way about Android, Windows, Linux...

7: Available on most other products aimed at business too. Home users don't tend to care so much.

8: Ummm, OK. Ubuntu has similar, so hardly a OSX unique thing. And hardly a massive reason to spend extra on an Apple computer.

9: Price of OSX - lower. Price of Mac to run it on - far higher (Macbook Air seems to be an exception - to the point I'm considering getting one).

10: I wonder if the team that developed this were playing on their Wii Fit when they "thought" of this one...


10 September 2011, 2:26 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

PB (New user):

3. "Autosave" in Mac OSX is to "Previous Versions" in windows 7. This covers everything from office to even programs and applications so its nothing new.

05 January 2012, 5:55 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymousewiuu2945u389 (User):

Not really... I'm fairly sure that Previous Versions doesn't automatically activate Control-S every few minutes. The 'Versions' system maybe, but not autosave.

12 February 2012, 4:13 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

PB (New user):

Quoting Tin:
3: This actually sounds kind of interesting and clever. Useful even, since it makes it simple for developers to implement autosave. One less common task for devs to do.

Not really, Windows Vista and 7 has "Previous Versions" which not only auto saves office docs but even applications and just about anything in the PC.




05 January 2012, 6:00 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JimmyBoyFromOz (User):

If you revert to previous versions in windows you get it all back.
Versions in Lion gives you graphical view of earlier versions of documents etc that you can selectively pick which one you want.
The OS is detecting you changed something in the document (even in memory) and it is not a Cmd S or autosave every ten minutes or anything like that. Cmd S saves a specific version but if you edit for any time the current version is whatever you are up to and closing the app doesn't require the save dialog

12 February 2012, 10:21 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Fridge Magnet (User):

Interesting article. I've been a PC user my whole life so far. I have used various versions of Linux, Ubuntu however I mainly use Windows. I'm long overdue for an upgrade and I this time I was decided to keep an open mind and check out Apple's offerings. The first time i used their iMac 21" at a store, it quite frankly blew me away. The GUI is awesome and extremely user friendly. I was put off Mac in 2000-2004 when I was using their clunky old version with an extremely different interface.

To any buyer who wants reliability and a hassle free product I would probably recommend a Mac over a PC these days unless you must have Windows. I'm not an Apple fanboy, I don't own any of their products but their Macbook Air product line absolutely blows all their competitors out of the water with its battery life, screen, performance, reliability and most suprising for an Apple product: its price. So awesome for a Uni student or people who do light to medium computing away from a power source.

The price of OS Lion is probably the aspect i find most appealing. You get an OS that is on par if not greater (at least in reliability) than Windows for $30. Unbeatable value? I'm not sure if Windows can compete with that especially since for most users OS Lion will run almost all their software with virtualisation.

11 September 2011, 8:32 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

hateyoursignupBS (New user):

So tired of fanboy articles that don't state why OSX is not the hotshot they claim it to be.

1. Lion, causes many programs to break. My apps are more important than a few added "features."
2. App store sucks, can you imagine the outcry if MS created this? It's a nightmare for end users and devs.
3. iCloud sucks. If you are Apple fanboi and have an iPad, iPhone, Mac great! you are good to go. if you choose superior equipment (not iPhone, not iPad) you are screwed. Wow, that reminds me of how MS works.
4. "improved" app switching? rubbish. Why won't all app windows open when I click on the icon on the dock? poor design.
5. OSX i overpriced. >90% of OSX is FREE, and they charge for it? R U Serious?
6. Multiple licenses are cheap? WTF, Snow Leopard I could us on UNLIMITED machines. It was even trumpeted in the ad!

I use a Mac, and I regret switching, some days. But, I am honest about it's faults.

27 September 2011, 7:42 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Mike Poole (New user):

You should name the broken apps. I use Lion constantly on multiple machines around 12 hours a day as the leader of an editing and writing team. I've never had a an app that has broken.


03 February 2012, 5:33 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

hateyoursignupBS (New user):

So tired of fanboy articles that don't state why OSX is not the hotshot they claim it to be.

1. Lion, causes many programs to break. My apps are more important than a few added "features."
2. App store sucks, can you imagine the outcry if MS created this? It's a nightmare for end users and devs.
3. iCloud sucks. If you are Apple fanboi and have an iPad, iPhone, Mac great! you are good to go. if you choose superior equipment (not iPhone, not iPad) you are screwed. Wow, that reminds me of how MS works.
4. "improved" app switching? rubbish. Why won't all app windows open when I click on the icon on the dock? poor design.
5. OSX i overpriced. >90% of OSX is FREE, and they charge for it? R U Serious?
6. Multiple licenses are cheap? WTF, Snow Leopard I could us on UNLIMITED machines. It was even trumpeted in the ad!

I use a Mac, and I regret switching, some days. But, I am honest about it's faults.

27 September 2011, 7:42 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

hateyoursignupBS (New user):

So tired of fanboi articles that don't state why OSX is not the hotshot they claim it to be.

1. Lion, causes many programs to break. My apps are more important than a few added "features."
2. App store sucks, can you imagine the outcry if MS created this? It's a nightmare for end users and devs.
3. iCloud sucks. If you are Apple fanboi and have an iPad, iPhone, Mac great! you are good to go. if you choose superior equipment (not iPhone, not iPad) you are screwed. Wow, that reminds me of how MS works.
4. "improved" app switching? rubbish. Why won't all app windows open when I click on the icon on the dock? poor design.
5. OSX i overpriced. >90% of OSX is FREE to Apple
6. Lion Server is finally a decent price, BUT THEY DON’T HAVE SERVERS.
7. If you buy Apple products you are supporting eco-nazis, Obama, algore and his private jet tour preaching to you about not flying!
8. Apple Hardware is WAY overpriced.

I use a Mac, and I regret switching, some days. It’s not the great experience the fanbois claim.

27 September 2011, 7:55 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

hateyoursignupBS (New user):

I click SUBMIT once and it posts 3 times. Nice.

funny this site looks like a MS site (top bar.)

27 September 2011, 7:58 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Dave192 (New user):

I use Lion at home and Win7 at work. I have to admit I like Lion heaps better for different reasons.

1. No REGISTRY. Anyone with half a brain would know why.
2. No driver issues. Which by the way is worse on Win7 then WinXP and that was bad
3. Installing and uninstalling on Windows is a complicated process and even then it still doens't get rid of everything. With Mac os X just copy to Applications folder to install and drag it to the trash in uninstall. Simple.
4. no profile corruption issues. Trust me I have had to deal with many problems with corrupt profiles, and it's just as bad if not worse on Win7 then XP.
5. Auto-save and Resume is brilliant. Works like a charm.
6. App store is great. So conveniant and loads of great apps.

28 October 2011, 8:10 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (User):

Quoting Dave192:
1. No REGISTRY. Anyone with half a brain would know why.

Aside from it growing too big, I find the registry to be fine these days. It does cause us some hassles when something corrupts it, but that's normally dead HDD or RAM, which will corrupt anything it touches.

Quoting Dave192:
2. No driver issues. Which by the way is worse on Win7 then WinXP and that was bad

You're doing it wrong then. We actually changed our pricing for Windows reinstalls at work for Windows 7 because we don't need to spend half an hour figuring out what drivers to use.
As for Mac drivers - I've had plenty of devices not work and not have easily obtained drivers.


Quoting Dave192:
3. Installing and uninstalling on Windows is a complicated process and even then it still doens't get rid of everything. With Mac os X just copy to Applications folder to install and drag it to the trash in uninstall. Simple.

And if said application has dumped modules into the system folder? Or if you sit down at someone else's Mac to run a program and have to find it in Documents or some other stupid place (I'm not making that up - I've seen it)?

Quoting Dave192:
4. no profile corruption issues. Trust me I have had to deal with many problems with corrupt profiles, and it's just as bad if not worse on Win7 then XP.

I've honestly only ever seen that with roaming profiles on Windows domains or where malware has been involved. And in both cases, it's usually down to user stupidity (like turning off the computer while it's logging on/off).


Quoting Dave192:
5. Auto-save and Resume is brilliant. Works like a charm.

Now that one IS a good idea - but hardly a reason to buy a Mac over anything else.

Quoting Dave192:
6. App store is great. So conveniant and loads of great apps.

I never really had a problem downloading zip files, etc and installing software distributed outside of the greed of a major software vendor. All this App Store business is about is making 30% for Apple.

28 October 2011, 3:57 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Dave192 (New user):

"You're doing it wrong then. We actually changed our pricing for Windows reinstalls at work for Windows 7 because we don't need to spend half an hour figuring out what drivers to use.
As for Mac drivers - I've had plenty of devices not work and not have easily obtained drivers."

I don't think there is a wrong way of doing it. Drivers are installed eith by an exe, or manually installing via device manager (perferably). My experience is that the drivers work perfectly for some time then out of the blue they just stop working for no reason at all. These are just HP univeral print drivers too, nothing fancy. The only way to reinstall them is to delete them from the registry and the drivers from the spooler folders hence the reason why I cannot stand the registry.

"I've honestly only ever seen that with roaming profiles on Windows domains or where malware has been involved. And in both cases, it's usually down to user stupidity (like turning off the computer while it's logging on/off)."

On a domain system, I have seen profile corruption happen without the user doing anything to provoke it. Again, the only way to reset the local profile is to delete a registry key and then rename the corrupt profile. This is an extra step from XP.

I also find the system preference more intuitive and easier then the Windows control panel. For me it takes less clicks to do things then Windows.

Don't get me wrong. I don't hate Windows, I just perfer Mac.

01 November 2011, 8:45 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

marco75 (User):

How well does Lion work in desktop virtualization software? For $31.99, I would like to try it once I get a new machine with i5 & 8 GB RAM. :-)

I used Macs before and I found it hard to switch after using MS-DOS/Windows all my life. Simple things like window management, AeroSnap, drag'N drop through the taskbar, Clover + C instead of Ctrl + C etc.

Good repartee to the Windows eats OSX article in the print version, though. They should have printed this one too, just the one side makes APC look biased.

07 November 2011, 11:20 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

sprocket (New user):

This article is retarded, it depends on the user as to what OS is better, I use my PC for gaming hence Windows 7 is better than any mac os for me. Again, what a stupid article, and to think I used to read APC mags...

02 December 2011, 12:41 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

sprocket (New user):

What a stupid article, it depends on the user as to what OS is better. Windows 7 is way better for me, as I use my PC primarily for gaming. Again what a stupid article, and i used to read this mag...

02 December 2011, 12:44 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

MM007 (New user):

Firstly, that is the most biased s**t I have ever read in my entire life. Here's a little list: 1. Adhoc- intant connection between two computers, 2. (Not only is the argument invalid because the software is designed for the hardware, Xbox's start up faster (beat Mac there too) Windows 8 starts up faster on HDD than Lion does on SSD.)3. Most apps auto back up anyway (AND most apps on Apple are made by apple so that's an unfiar argument as well) 4. "Virtual Desktops". Wow.(Sarcasm) I've never seen something so useful. Maybe... Hmm... Remote desktop? That's a tiy bit more useful.. "just a silky smooth horizontal scroll." Sums up Apple. 5. App switching on Windows is incredibly easy - ever heard of the start bar? On OS X it's tonnes of seperate blobs, where as on Windows it's actually organized. And to get to level where you need the Mac one you need about a 1000 programs running, which is far beyond the capability of either OS. 6. People are so ridiculously stupid. Skydrive and Google Docs have had perfect syncing with Windows Phones and Androids millenium before Icloud, and do everything Icloud does. Windows and Google definitely win that one. 7. Orrr you just but a harddrive password on? Or a BIOS password on? But of course, that's nearly unreachable because it's a MAC! 8. An app store. Wow.(Sarcasm) Not only is that coming in Windows 8... I'm sure there's a massive selection of software available! Because all of the money for businesses is in "MAC OS X!" 9. Price is absolute bulls(&t because in order to benefit from the price you need to buy at least 10 Mac's which are all ready twice the price of normal computerse. 10. Ever heard of Microsoft digital services? Hope that clears a few things up.

So there's my little list.

09 December 2011, 5:06 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

MM007 (New user):

Firstly, that is the most biased s**t I have ever read in my entire life. Here's a little list: 1. Adhoc- intant connection between two computers, 2. (Not only is the argument invalid because the software is designed for the hardware, Xbox's start up faster (beat Mac there too) Windows 8 starts up faster on HDD than Lion does on SSD.)3. Most apps auto back up anyway (AND most apps on Apple are made by apple so that's an unfiar argument as well) 4. "Virtual Desktops". Wow.(sarcasm) I've never seen something so useful. Maybe... Hmm... Remote desktop? That's a tiy bit more useful.. "just a silky smooth horizontal scroll." Sums it up. 5. App switching on Windows is incredibly easy - ever heard of the start bar? On the Mac it's tonnes of seperate blobs, where as on Windows it's actually organized. And to get to level where you need the Mac one you need about a 1000 programs running, which is far beyond the capability of either OS. 6. People are so ridiculously stupid. Skydrive and Google Docs have had perfect syncing with Windows Phones and Androids millenium before Icloud, and do everything Icloud does. Windows and Google definitely win that one. 7. Orrr you just but a harddrive password on? Or a BIOS password on? But of course, that's nearly unreachable because it's a MAC. 8. An app store. Wow. Not only is that coming in Windows 8... I'm sure there's a massive selection of software available! Because all of the money for businesses is in "MAC OS X!(sarcasm)" 9. Price is absolute bulls**t because in order to benefit from the price you need to buy 10 Mac's which is all ready twice the price. "NO further explanation required." 10. Ever heard of digital services in Office? Hope that clears a few things up.

09 December 2011, 5:16 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Daniel Hall (New user):

Hi there,
I was once like you where I thought Macs where no different from PC's, until I bought a Mac! It is so much better then a PC!!!!!!!! I have used windows I did so since we had a 95. Yeah they have the "Start" button, but i takes forever to see all of the programs and it doesn't evan show them all!!! Mac's however have an app called "LaunchPad" with is a lot like "Start", but it is much easer to use and your able to clearly see all of you app! Also an i5 processor is standard on all Mac's, but to get one on maybe 40% of PC's you have to acutely buy the i5 separate. Yeah so what the cheapest Mac is $800 big ones, but it's worth every penny!!!! I love Mac and always will!!!!!! Yes Windows wi;; have an app store, but Mac already does. So the competitors copies the leader again just like they copied the iPhone an iPad. Apple is the leader while everyone els are either following or staying put. Mac also has a spell check like the iPhone.

18 December 2011, 1:12 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymousewiuu2945u389 (User):

Quoting Daniel Hall:
It is so much better then a PC!!!!!!!!

No it isn't - better is only an opinion that varies from person to person. There are some things about Mac OS X that I like, just as there are things about Windows. But since I prefer upgradeability, it's PCs for me.

Quoting Daniel Hall:
but i takes forever to see all of the programs and it doesn't evan (sic) show them all

That's OK for me, I only need to see the one that I want - I can't remember the last time I used the programs menu on Vista/7 (I only ever use the search bar, activated by the keyboard). And my experience has been that XP and earlier are capable of sprouting a whole screen worth of programs.

Quoting Daniel Hall:
Also an i5 processor is standard on all Mac's, but to get one on maybe 40% of PC's you have to acutely buy the i5 separate.

That's not a good thing for those people who only need an i3...

Quoting Daniel Hall:
Yes Windows wi;; have an app store, but Mac already does.

Meh. I don't like the anticompetitive messes known as modern-day app stores, at least as implemented by Apple and Microsoft. Also, Linux has had similar functionality since the dawn of time, except without paid apps until recently.

Quoting Daniel Hall:
Apple is the leader while everyone els are either following or staying put.

How so? All they seem to do is take other people's ideas, apply some spit and polish and market it as the world's next big (one more) thing.

01 January 2012, 7:19 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymousewiuu2945u389 (User):

Double-post deleted.

01 January 2012, 7:19 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Julian Lockhart (New user):

Well after 15 years or so I am back to a mac. Here is something that Impresses me: Transferring 650gb to other drive while reading this article, listening to tunes and whatever else catches my fancy. No slow performance no stutter of the sound. And the mission control thingy is superb.

29 December 2011, 10:46 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (User):

If you're impressed that the new computer you can be copying data and playing music at the same time, I suspect you were doing it wrong before.

29 December 2011, 5:46 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

RJs (New user):

I bought a imac with Lion already installed, i have always used apple but this will be my last. Lion os is garbage. I could not install Leopard onto the new imac but I managed to copy it to a partition. It works way better than Lion. I will not go into the problems of Lion there are just to many to list. I have an ssd drive which i have to begrudgingly share with Lion OS. Basically I have been ripped off.


29 December 2011, 11:24 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JimmyBoyFromOz (User):

You can remove Lion.
Go through installer and after accepting language (first step) go into the tools menu and run disk utility and blow away the hidden lion partition and the main partition and create a single new one.
Then install Lion via a USB key. It is easy to make it just get any mac with access to SL install DVD and plug in a USB an using disk utility choose restore from the DVD to the USB and when finished you have a self booting USB key. Hold option key down while booting and choose the USB and away you go

01 January 2012, 4:08 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JimmyBoyFromOz (User):

errata I meant install Sl from USB key but I guess you got the idea :-)
Quoting RJs:
I could not install Leopard onto the new imac




01 January 2012, 4:11 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

RJs (New user):

I bought a imac with Lion already installed, i have always used apple but this will be my last. Lion os is garbage. I could not install Leopard onto the new imac but I managed to copy it to a partition. It works way better than Lion. I will not go into the problems of Lion there are just to many to list. I have an ssd drive which i have to begrudgingly share with Lion OS. Basically I have been ripped off.


29 December 2011, 11:26 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

View all comments (84)  

anonymous user Anonymous user