It's time to declare the UMPC D.O.A.

Send to a friend Print

Help more people find out about this story

Del.icio.us
StumbleUpon

Ian Grayson20 July 2007, 5:56 AM

The Ultra-Mobile PC has failed to entice users. Is it destined to go the way of Bill Gates' favourite innovation, the tablet PC?


Samsung's Q1Samsung's Q1
Trumpeted as the next "must have" device for the techno-savvy traveller, the Ultra Mobile PC is still being shunned by major hardware vendors and virtually ignored by users.

Backed by heavyweights Microsoft and Intel, and launched last year amid an intense viral marketing campaign, the UMPC hasn't managed to rate even a blip on sales radars.

By establishing its Origami specification for the UMPC, Microsoft had hoped to kick-start activity in what is a new and untested product category. Sitting awkwardly between notebook PCs and PDAs, UMPCs are designed to give full PC power in a package that can be easily slung in a bag or jacket pocket.

But so far the big PC vendors have shown no interest in climbing aboard the UMPC bandwagon, preferring to focus their efforts on ultra-portable notebook PCs instead.

"The market is clearly dictating that this is not a product they are ready for," says Dell Australia's client computing strategist Jeff Morris. "You have to make a lot of trade offs in terms of screen size and performance."

HP Australia's market development manager for commercial notebooks Janet Bradburn says the new devices are coming up in conversations with customers, but these flickers of interest are a long way from translating into any sort of significant sales. Her company has no plans to add one to its product line-up.

Toshiba, too, is holding off on the whole UMPC category, claiming there is simply no demand in the market for them.

"The UMPC will fade as notebook PCs become more portable," says Toshiba product manager Justin White. "We are just not seeing a lot of demand for them."

Not to be deterred, Microsoft is still touting the concept as a viable alternative for those who don't want to carry a notebook PC, yet need more grunt than can be delivered by a PDA or smartphone. It's convinced people are happy to forego a keyboard and big screen for the benefits of portability.

One vendor which has nailed its colours to the UMPC mast is Samsung. It's latest, the Q1 Ultra, comes in a variety of models. One, aimed at business users, contains a 60GB hard drive and retails for $US1199.


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Danny Gorog:

Good article Ian.

You really gain an appreciation for how 'customer-centric' mainstream PC manufacturers understand the consumer by the crap products they release.

UMPCs (and tablet PCs for that matter) shouldn't have made it off the drawing board. I feel sorry for anyone that wasted their money on them.



29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (9 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

blip:

Two words. Apple Newton.

29 February 2008, 8:46 PM (9 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

zahadum:

not sure if you are trying to suggest:

a) that the newton was a great idea ahead of its time (it created the whole pda category) ...

and that it would have become an even more amazing device if steve jobs hadnt killed it (like he did to some many other innovation during his intellectual pogroms at the apple labs)

b) apple withdrew a product from market (even though it worked) whereas microsoft , that would be the zune!?)

29 February 2008, 8:46 PM (9 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

tin:

One word: (Toshiba) Libretto.

Considering the number of external keyboards sold to add to PDAs, I really think the giant PDA UMPC is pointless. It's similar size to the Toshiba Libretto anyway, so why not get something with a real keyboard. If the price is not nice enough, the Asus Eee is pretty small too.

29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (9 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tony:

Let's just hope Microsoft keeps on wasting money on dead ends like this one. This story coupled with the expensive Xbox problems, and the dud Zune too, makes one wonder where Microsoft is heading.

A weakened Microsoft would be a good thing and probably well deserved given its nasty business practices.

Microsoft might eventually realise it should concentrate on its core businesses once again a la Vista SP1 which fixes all the problems as well as giving its patient and tolerant customers new useful things. Wasn't there once talk of a new ubeaut file system for Vista...what about getting Vista 64 extra mileage too (make it really secure), and dropping prices M$?


29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (9 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags