How much data do you need for your iPhone 3G?

ANALYSIS: How much data do you need for iPhone 3G?

Danny Gorog09 July 2008, 3:55 PM

With the news that not all iPhone plans are created equal, the big unanswered question for newly minted iPhone 3G owners around the world is: how much data is enough?


Before we delve into that discussion we need to look at who the 'average' iPhone 3G user is. In some cases with iPhone 3Gs costing customers $0 upfront, the range of 'average' will be large. Let's take a few different scenarios:

I've been using the first generation iPhone since July last year. I'm a Virgin mobile customer, and pay $10 per month for 300MB. I have an IMAP email account setup on my iPhone, and I have it set to check email every 15 minutes. On average I get around 40 emails per day. I also surf on my iPhone extensively (but normally to iPhone optimised sites, like Google Reader for iPhone) - whenever I'm not near my computer. I check share prices, and have recently installed an IM client too. In the twelve months I've had my iPhone the most GPRS data I've used is around 130MB. But at home I've got my iPhone connected on my WiFi network, and during the day I've also got access to WiFi. I consider myself a 'heavy' data user.

My friend, on the other-hand, works as a doctor in a local hospital. He's currently on a $49 Optus capped plan and checks his email and surfs occasionally. He told me that last month he only used 1.5MB but other times has used 10 or 15MB per month. He has access to a computer at work, so prefers to surf and check email on that.

I think it's safe to assume that most iPhone 3G customers will have access to broadband Internet at least at home, and likely at work. This means that surfing/checking email on the iPhone will be limited to times they are 'out and about', travelling to and from work etc.

To determine what 100MB of data (the amount that Optus provide on their base $19 plan) gets you, I've made the following assumptions:
Average email size is 15KB
Average complete webpage is 1MB
Average 'iPhone' optimised webpage is 20KB
Average size of iPhone Apps is 5MB
A month has 30 days

So, here's what you 'do' with a the 100MB of data that Optus are providing on their $19 plan?
- 6000 emails per month, or 220 per day
- 100 web pages per month, or 3.4 per day
- 5000 iPhone optimised web pages per month, or 166 per day
- 20 iPhone Apps per month, or less than 1 per day

Obviously, usage will be a combination of all three, but you'll quickly realise that 100MB will go along way for the average consumer. I'd also anticipate that on average, people will select a $49 plan which includes 250MB of data which, based on the same set of assumptions gets you the following:
- 16,600 emails per month, or 555 per day
- 250 web pages per month, or 8.3 per day
- 12,500 iPhone optimised web pages per month, 416 per day.
- 50 iPhone Apps per month, or less than 1.6 per day

No doubt, there will be users that need more than 250MB -- especially people that watch a lot of YouTube videos streamed over the mobile network -- however, I'd anticipate that very few users will actually be able to use more than 250MB of data per month. While iPhone 3G offers a superb mobile experience, it's still no substitute for a full computer experience. However, it's also worth remembering that carriers will charge you blind if you exceed your data caps, so monitoring your data usage over the first month is worthwhile.

iPhone 3G has a built-in usage meter (found in settings->usage) that tells you 3G/EDGE data, but that, of course, isn't the definitive measurement. It's what the carrier measures on the network-side that they'll bill you on, so it's important to check your usage with the carrier.

So far, Optus has told APC that  customers will be able to view their data usage via the 'MyUsage' section in the 'MyAccount' section on the Optus website. Prepaid customers (only) will be able to SMS "balance" to 9999 to get a reading on their prepaid data balance. We haven't yet heard from Vodafone or Telstra on how their customers will be able to keep tabs on their iPhone data usage.

Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Me In Oz (Cornerstone member):

Yes but we humans are consumers extrordinaire.
When broadband started I thought 500 meg was huge and would never fill the monthly quota. Now 10-15 gig is barely enough !
(Wife does publishing work from home, though ..... and I have to stop visiting Hoot ......... :)

09 July 2008, 3:48 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Danny Gorog (APC staff):

true, but until somebody develops a bittorrent client for iPhone think we are OK for a while.

09 July 2008, 3:55 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Me In Oz (Cornerstone member):

Quoting Danny Gorog:
true, but until somebody develops a bittorrent client for iPhone


Oh It's coming, Danny !

09 July 2008, 4:33 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Hemma (User):

BT on an iPhone.... that is going to kill the battery!

09 July 2008, 6:02 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Ed Dale (New user):

I have a current iPhone - I've used 308mb since last Saturday on my iPhone -

09 July 2008, 4:07 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Danny Gorog (APC staff):

wow! doing what?

09 July 2008, 4:41 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Hemma (User):

I think generally, the more speed you have, the more you would download.... not to mention that you could probably download MP3's straight off the phone.... then there's the odd trailer here and there... Browsing is only restricted to the capability of the device.... i don't download anything on my Nokia, not because of the speed, but the technology is a little limited for me to do so. But iPhone is more like a UMPC (in some sense) and that's going to open the floodgates to the amount of stuff you would do.

09 July 2008, 6:06 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

agami (User):

Additional variables to this calculation is Wi-Fi availability on the plus side and Google Maps on the minus side.

Since data actually costs the providers less than 0.1ยข per MB we're being robbed anyway you look at it.

09 July 2008, 4:22 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Danny Gorog (APC staff):

yeah, but thank god there's competition in our local market. Poor NZ and Canada.

09 July 2008, 4:42 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

McBanjo (User):

YouTube would be the biggest sapper I'd reckon. After that Google Maps would be quite data intensive. Do we know how much data Google Maps uses, or an idea? Other than that, data usage would be very minimal.

On another note, how long does it take to download on iPhone 1.0? How much would say the "Test your Awareness Ad" over YouTube take to download on GPRS?

Note to iPhone 1.0 users, Mxtube is a great app that lets you save your Youtube videos for later, you should check it out. It's pretty awesome.

09 July 2008, 6:16 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (Senior Forumologist):

Re: downloading youtube videos...
There's a semi-official Javascript code chunklet you can use to make a download link appear on Youtube pages. It then allows you to download a copy of the video in MPEG4 (which iPods and iPhones can play, can't they?).
Do a Google search for "youtube mp4" (no quotes) and you should find the details...

10 July 2008, 9:24 AM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Jeff (User):

If I got an iPhone I would probably kill the limit in the first couple of months, just because it was new and after that I would probably hardly use it at all...

09 July 2008, 6:35 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

calmtechcoach (New user):

the sad thing is that we will HAVE to restrain ourselves - no random downloads of itunes songs/movies as we feel like it..... etc........
i think the plans so far are very very scrooge-like....

09 July 2008, 7:45 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

topgold (New user):

You have to be on a data diet if you're consuming less than a gig a month on the phone. I've been running with Nokia Series 60 phones for a little more than two years and never come under the 250 MB benchmark. I do a lot of photostreams and Qik videos. In my field of work, the phone is a recorder and a player more than a voice instrument. It is simply not just a textual device.

10 July 2008, 6:10 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

morodashortass (New user):

I would be seriously interested in getting a 16GB iPhone with Optus, but I am a very big youtube user and am guessing that regardless of whether youtube is iPhone optimised (which I believe it is, data usage for someone like me would be huge.

For example, I have cable broadband with optus (12GB normal usage, 24GB off peak usage which is between 12 and 12)and every month, I use all 12GB of normal usage and probably half of the off peak, a high percentage of which would be on youtube.

So can someone evaluate for me roughly how much data I would consume on an iPhone given I watch an estimated 30-40 videos on youtube per day?

10 July 2008, 8:26 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

whateva (New user):

In reply to morodashortass's question about how much you may need; I estimate 4 to 6 GB..;; here is how i worked it out;
I just saved a chunk of Youtoube videos last night from my cache. 65 of the video clips came to a total of 462MB. They each ranged in side from a few hundred kilobytes, to the largest one being 24 MB. This averages to 7.05MB from my sampling. Your viewing habits may be different. You could watch shorter or you could watch longer videos, which will affect the amount of data. I have not taken into account, the actual page, which i am guestimating (from a very small sample of saved HTML pages) to be a few hundred kilobytes per view; lets give it an average of .25mb, which brings the average video to 7.3mB per view. Then you will need to add a small amount for searches, which is relatively small in comparison to average video size, so i will leave it out. ;;;
;;;;;; For 20 to 30 videos, based on my sampling of the types of videos i watched (which, as i said, could differ for you, but it does give you some idea, rather than what appears to me to be unrealistic data given in this news article);;

Ok, for 20 to 30 videos per day, my guestimate = 136MB - 219MB per day
times 30 days in the month = 4080 MB to 6120MB (4 to 6GB per month)
_________________________________________________________________

what???? 15kb for an average email. Maybe 10 years ago (for an average email, where emails were more text than they are today), and MAYBE for my grandmother, who only uses text, and may not send photos.

If i were to receive a photos in my email from a modern day camera, that could be in excess of 2MB for EACH photo. Now, if i had to pay Telstra's $2 per megabyte excess, that could get mighty expensive. (i certainly would not want to be watching 4000 to 6000 MB of Youtube, at that excess fee rate)Of course, Optus would be willing to dramatically slash that to an excess of 35cents per megabyte, and if your 4 to 6 GB of excess were from YoutTubing, you could be paying $1400 to $2100 in excess for that one month. Much cheaper than Telstra, hey. (Save $5400 to$8100 in excess), and get a free bolt of lighting from discovering your first bill if you did not do your sums from the start, rather than believe their hype. So faster 3G networks claimed by one of the main carriers may not of much use unless you have money to burn.

22 July 2008, 5:05 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

whateva (New user):

In reply to morodashortass's question about how much you may need; I estimate 4 to 6 GB..;; here is how i worked it out;
I just saved a chunk of Youtoube videos last night from my cache. 65 of the video clips came to a total of 462MB. They each ranged in side from a few hundred kilobytes, to the largest one being 24 MB. This averages to 7.05MB from my sampling. Your viewing habits may be different. You could watch shorter or you could watch longer videos, which will affect the amount of data. I have not taken into account, the actual page, which i am guestimating (from a very small sample of saved HTML pages) to be a few hundred kilobytes per view; lets give it an average of .25mb, which brings the average video to 7.3mB per view. Then you will need to add a small amount for searches, which is relatively small in comparison to average video size, so i will leave it out. ;;;
;;;;;; For 20 to 30 videos, based on my sampling of the types of videos i watched (which, as i said, could differ for you, but it does give you some idea, rather than what appears to me to be unrealistic data given in this news article);;

Ok, for 20 to 30 videos per day, my guestimate = 136MB - 219MB per day
times 30 days in the month = 4080 MB to 6120MB (4 to 6GB per month)
_________________________________________________________________

what???? 15kb for an average email. Maybe 10 years ago (for an average email, where emails were more text than they are today), and MAYBE for my grandmother, who only uses text, and may not send photos.

If i were to receive a photos in my email from a modern day camera, that could be in excess of 2MB for EACH photo. Now, if i had to pay Telstra's $2 per megabyte excess, that could get mighty expensive. (i certainly would not want to be watching 4000 to 6000 MB of Youtube, at that excess fee rate)Of course, Optus would be willing to dramatically slash that to an excess of 35cents per megabyte, and if your 4 to 6 GB of excess were from YoutTubing, you could be paying $1400 to $2100 in excess for that one month. Much cheaper than Telstra, hey. (Save $5400 to$8100 in excess), and get a free bolt of lighting from discovering your first bill if you did not do your sums from the start, rather than believe their hype. So faster 3G networks claimed by one of the main carriers may not of much use unless you have money to burn.

22 July 2008, 5:05 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

morodashortass (New user):

I would like to get a 16GB iPhone with optus (who I am currently with for 12GB regular/24GB off peak cable broadband, 2 digital television set top boxes, home phone and 2 mobiles on plans) so I am disappointed that such commitment would not bring some level of discount.

Anyway, if I got an iPhone 90%+ of my data usage would come from viewing youtube and other streaming video sites, with emails occasionally being checked in hotmail as well as ebay viewing. I would probably watch 20-30 videos max a day, though some of these would be fairly long.

What level of data usage would I be looking at to maintain such browsing habits? Is youtube optimised for iPhone viewing (last week I tried a 8GB touch at the Apple Store in Sydney and it ran youtube pretty well, though I wouldn't know how much data I consumed in the 20 minutes I spent browsing it's features)

Lastly, if I was to download videos from youtube on my PC, convert them to MP4 format and sync like I would to a regualr iPod, this would likely allow me to decrease my daily video viewing habits, so please take this into account when suggesting either caps, plans or pre-paid options for me.

10 July 2008, 8:38 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Raindog (Senior Forumologist):

Quoting morodashortass:
so I am disappointed that such commitment would not bring some level of discount.


Why in heck would any business discount something in short supply that people are silly enough to queue in the cold over?

Discounts begin when the foolishness ceases and people get back to their lives however menial they may be. This is "supply and demand" in operation.



11 July 2008, 1:23 PM (1 year ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags