BILL EXPLOSION: Google Android silently phones home

David Neiger
05 January 2009, 4:20 PM


Users of imported Google Android smartphones have got a nasty shock, with their mobile phone bills showing massive unexpected SMS usage.


Just like E.T., the T-Mobile G1 smartphones were desperately trying to phone home (via international SMS) to the original carrier T-mobile but did not indicate they were doing so.

One user on Whirlpool found that his T-Mobile G1 (HTC Dream) made 200 International SMS calls whilst another user was hit with 1329 International SMS messages.

It seems the phones were dialling a pre-set T-mobile network number (453) which Virgin mobile treats as an International SMS number at 35c per message. Ironically Virgin probably never even delivered the SMS but charged the user anyway.

The problem with the T-mobile G1 is that buried amongst all of the applications is myFaves which is responsible for clandestinely sending the SMS messages without the phone owner’s knowledge. On the T-mobile network there are no additional charges, but as soon as the phone roams (or is switched) to another carrier, the costs start piling up.

The solution apparently is to jailbreak the phone and flash it with UK firmware which does not phone home. If you have RC29 firmware, that is an option but with the RC30 firmware, a jailbreak is not yet available, and the phone can't be reflashed.

Optus (Virgin mobile’s owner) claims that it is unable to block international SMS without totally disabling all SMS functionality. Nor, they claim, are they able to block specific SMS numbers (even if they don’t work).

Even if you live in the US and bring take your phone overseas you could also be in for some fairly hefty roaming charges. Apparently the T-mobile version of the G1 does not allow you to turn off data roaming even if you manually disable data roaming, data sync and 3G. We understand that the T-mobile G1 always accesses the Internet whether you are sending text messages or placing calls. The advice from T-mobile is “the phone should have be left in the USA to avoid these [data roaming] charges.” )

The lesson from this is to be extremely careful when importing any smartphone from overseas, as there may be some carrier features buried in the firmware which if not properly disabled will cost you unexpected data or SMS charges.

iPhone users should also beware. If you take your phone overseas make sure you disable data roaming from the menus or be prepared for some hefty phone bills as applications on the iPhone may also chatter away over the internet without your knowledge.


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Michael Quinn (New user):

Hilarious. Open Source at its finest ! So much for being open and able to edit / fix whats going on.

05 January 2009, 5:04 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

AndyCee (New user):

Quoting Michael Quinn:
Open Source at its finest !


Err...doesn't this apply to the iPhone as well?

05 January 2009, 7:35 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (User):

Ummm, it's t-Mobile's app causing the problem, not the open source parts.

The headline is purposely misleading, BTW...

05 January 2009, 8:13 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Aubrey (New user):

Quoting Michael Quinn:
Hilarious. Open Source at its finest ! So much for being open and able to edit / fix whats going on.

Yeah? Seems the telco involved closed-sourced key elements of the firmware and that's where the problem resides - not in the android itself or in the OSS components. This is actually a very good argument for keeping the whole kit Open Source (and keeping your telco or isp at arms-length from your technology, IMO)



06 January 2009, 9:52 AM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

WorldWideJeb (New user):

The iPhone also "phones home" to Apple in Australia via a premium 19 SMS number. The carrier is not supposed to charge the customer for these messages, although A Particular Telco slipped up late last year and accidentally charged some customers for the messages (I think it happened if they were on pre-paid, or a non iPhone plan).

The purpose of the "phone home" is to check if Apple has flagged the carrier as capable of visual voicemail or not, I believe. Although who knows what else it's sending back to them...

05 January 2009, 7:36 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Dan Warne (Regular user):

REALLY!? First I'd heard of that. That's fascinating. Got a link to any further info?

05 January 2009, 10:08 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Carmar (New user):

I have a very ancient Nokia which will only phone home when I press the buttons - it may be low tech but at least it is cheap to run and does as it's told. I shudder every time I drop the thing on the floor in case it really breaks this time and I have to replace it with one of the smartphones. I love techno gadgets but who needs something as reliable as a carrier pigeon and 200 times more expensive?

06 January 2009, 3:16 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

WorldWideJeb (New user):

Dan - there is more info on the iPhone calls here and here. It's not a 19 number like I previously thought, but it still "phones home".

06 January 2009, 3:38 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Hemma (New user):

I know I'm beating a dead horse, but you can actually downgrade from the OTA RC30 firmware to RC29, then from that point you just Switch to either the ADP1 or RC8 firmware, avoiding the phone home problem....
I love this geeky phone.

09 January 2009, 10:14 AM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user