nikons
Nikon's D90 is the first DSLR to record in HD video.

DSLR Video: Is this the end of the camcorder as we know it?

Leigh Stark
01 October 2008, 9:18 AM


The first DSLR to record video in HD, Nikon's D90 digital SLR, is being joined by others and may signal the beginning of the end for the camcorder.


When Nikon announced that its new D90 digital SLR camera would be able to record video, most of the community was impressed but expected it. When it was revealed the camera would be recording in 720p, the eyes of photographers-now-amateur-filmmakers lit up with delight.

A few weeks later, someone over at Red, a high-end movie camera company, made mention that their new camera would be capable of 1080p. A week or two later, Canon made its new full-frame professional 5D Mark II known to the world with the 1080p capability that Red had mentioned. 

With capabilities such as this now coming to the high end sensors already available in semi-professional cameras, it was clear that the video camera market might begin to suffer. The question on everybody's lips is now...

Is this the end of the camcorder as we know it?

When MiniDV appeared in the late nineties, it was the thing to have. Models from Canon, Sony, Panasonic, and nearly every other major electronics manufacturer produced inexpensive video cameras which gave consumers the ability to craft DVD quality videos. While people had been making home movies for years, video had finally come to the masses.

Video cameras then stretched across multiple formats, recording on MiniDV tapes, hard drives, memory cards, DVD's, and nowadays Blu-ray discs. Prices range from as low as $300 to $2000 for a video camera that while it might be advanced, doesn't give you a whole lot of control.

But with the advent of video in a digital SLR,  if you go on a trip, you don't have to take along two cameras. It's less weight and and there's one less item to lose. And with the ability to change lenses on a digital SLR, a few things begin to happen. The type of shot you want begins to change significantly, with your choice of lens now taking precedent. Will you use a fish-eye to distort things, a kit lens as you walk around with the idea of shooting anything and everything, or a telephoto lens to get all the action from far away?

Once you see it from this point of view, you also quickly learn the the quality of the glass used in each lens is likely going to be better than that found on a video camera. It gets better because the sensors used on a digital SLR tend to be larger than regular digital video cameras giving you better clarity and an overall tendency to look more real.

But there's also a negative of the video-capable interchangeable lens camera, something that at least for the moment almost guarantees a life for Handycams for a few years more: auto-focus.

As it is now, this new breed of video cameras cannot focus while you're recording in the video mode. Digital SLR's have improved over the past few years to allow viewing by the screen and not just the viewfinder as well as to auto-focus within this mode, but focusing within video is just out of reach at the moment. This means that people looking to a Nikon D90 as an inexpensive highly adaptable camera still have to focus manually while Canon recommends that users of its Canon 5D Mark II  not use the auto-focus while filming. On the one hand, this could be seen as useful for those learning how to take packages but a pain to others who just want to take some video and not think about anything.

With these developments, it's clear that big camera companies are now taking aim at video cameras. Promising greater control in your film-making, this will be one area to watch.


Read more stories about

Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

agami (New user):

It's the middle of the end. The beginning of the end happened when still and motion went digital.

At the end of the day most consumers would like a single device that can film in HD and take high quality stills. Semi-Pro's, Pro's, and Pro-sumers will continue to insist on separate devices.

01 October 2008, 10:56 AM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

dbareis (New user):

The D90's video is too limiting, for example you can't change focus in middle. But yes I use my camera for video.

01 October 2008, 10:58 AM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (Regular user):

Quoting dbareis:
for example you can't change focus in middle


Why not? Can't you just turn the focus ring on the lens? It's an SLR after all.

02 October 2008, 12:27 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JGrant (New user):

"the sensors used on a digital SLR tend to be larger than regular digital video cameras giving you better clarity and an overall tendency to look more real."

Not sure what 'more real' is. There are plenty of advantages though. The dynamic range on these sensors is much broader, with size also comes the ability to work with shallow depth of field which is something videographers spend lots of money trying to achieve.
For instance: http://www.pstechnik.de/en/digitalfilm-mini35.php

Confusing time for us video guys!

01 October 2008, 11:25 AM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Peter Zhou (New user):

Is this the end of the camcorder the writer asks? In a few years, it will be the end of everything: the camcorder, the mobile phone, the iPod, the GPS device..we'll just carry a little digital black box that does everything.

01 October 2008, 12:44 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JRN, ACS (New user):

The focusing issue has been here since the beginning of the motion picture camera. It is a privalige to be able to follow focus and pull focus from subject to object that is a creative device not found too easily on Camcorders.They will always make camcorders for the tourists who want nothing beeter than have instant records havea look at Go Pro cameras absolutley amazing. The SLR Video cameras are a great breakthrough and Ive waited since I stoped shooting film for this developemnt to happen. There a a slewing problem Im told with SLRs so I wait till the gurus solve this before I buy a dedicated SLR camera. The Red Camera is now old fashioned but take great shots progress makes progress. Jon R. Noble ACS

23 March 2010, 7:05 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

JRN, ACS (New user):

The focusing issue has been here since the beginning of the motion picture camera. It is a privalige to be able to follow focus and pull focus from subject to object that is a creative device not found too easily on Camcorders.They will always make camcorders for the tourists who want nothing beeter than have instant records havea look at Go Pro cameras absolutley amazing. The SLR Video cameras are a great breakthrough and Ive waited since I stoped shooting film for this developemnt to happen. There a a slewing problem Im told with SLRs so I wait till the gurus solve this before I buy a dedicated SLR camera. The Red Camera is now old fashioned but take great shots progress makes progress. JRN, ACS

23 March 2010, 7:05 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user