iPad broadband plans will sting Australians

Please install the flash player

Renai LeMay01 February 2010, 10:30 AM

Apple's new iPad comes with a revolutionary new type of 3G plan -- in the US. But what can we expect from Australian telcos?


opinion One thing quickly became clear when Steve Jobs unveiled Apple’s newest “revolutionary” device last week.

If you want to get the full use out of your new iPad, you’ll want to buy the model which has a 3G mobile broadband connection built-in.

The iPad is clearly designed to function optimally when connected to the internet. The revamp of core Apple applications like Mail, Safari and iTunes, the ability to run all existing iPhone apps seamlessly and the great integration with Google Maps and YouTube all speak to the ideal of ubiquitous internet connectivity wherever a user is.

The sort of connectivity that tens of millions of people have already learned to depend on with their iPhone.

If you walk around Sydney’s Martin Place or Melbourne’s Lygon Street at lunchtime, you’ll see this phenomenon in action. Dozens of iPhone owners, head down, tapping away online, sometimes even walking at the same time.

There’s just one problem with this utopian iPad vision. It’s going to cost money. Lots of money.

Jobs may have created a new category of electronic device. But he’s also created a new category of wireless broadband plan to go with it..

The 3G-enabled version of the iPad already costs at least US$100 more than the model with just Wi-Fi. But the kicker is that users will also be required to sign up to a mobile broadband plan with a telco to use the 3G access. The device is unlocked, so theoretically users would be able to just insert an existing SIM card … if it weren’t for the fact that the iPad uses the new micro SIM or 3FF SIM format, which our existing devices don’t.

For most users, that will mean signing up for a second mobile plan, because the iPad is not capable of acting as a mobile phone. It just does data.

In the US, Jobs appears to cut the sort of unbelievable deal with AT&T that the Apple supremo is becoming famous for — users are being offered a choice of two plans, US$14.99 a month for 250MB of data or US$29.99 for unlimited.

But you can bet your sweet unmentionable that Jobs won’t be flying Down Under any time soon to sweet-talk one of our Australian telcos into a similar arrangement. Although Australian mobile broadband prices are steadily dropping, we’re still unlikely to reach a level where it’s trivial for most customers to add an iPad plan to their monthly grocery list.

To add a third plan to that list will seem to many to be unreasonable, unless telcos conduct some very serious bundling exercises.

The reason this affects Australia particularly is that many Australians, especially those in the early technology adopter community, already have both mobile phone and mobile broadband plans already through sheer geographical necessity. And mobile broadband numbers are growing fast.

We’re spread all over this wide brown land, we move around a lot, and there just ain’t enough Wi-Fi hotspots to go around.

The one thing that could mediate this reality would be for Apple to allow iPads to access 3G services through tethering with another device — even a customer’s existing iPhone. Internet forums have already started to light up with requests for just such a feature.

But Jobs didn’t give any indication this morning that tethering would be possible.

Of course, many Australians will simply swap their existing wireless broadband dongles for iPads and stop taking their laptops on the road. But my gut feeling is that most want to have their cake and eat it too — they want their iPhone, their MacBook with 3G, and an iPad. But they don’t want to pay for three mobile broadband connections.

Jobs may have created a new category of electronic device. But he’s also created a new category of wireless broadband plan to go with it.

The iPad is a great device. But, like so many Apple products, it’s one forgotten feature away from being perfect.

Delimiter

Read APC on your iPad now!

Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

apt.pupil (Cornerstone member):

the real question we should be asking ourselves is:
As a nation- how much longer will we tolerate being stung by Apple?
Did you know itunes music purchases in Australia are 40% higher than the US, and other countries- and then you add GST on top of that.
Apple stings its users overall with the extremely high price, and fast hardware upgrade cycles. For almost half the price of a Mac i could happily build a pc/linux computer with at least 30% more "umph", and know that it has been built just as correctly as an apple, albeit with a lot more personality and flair.

Its a good thing i am not allergic to annoying bug stings, or Apple would have killed me years ago

"like so many Apple products, it’s one forgotten feature away from being perfect."

which forgotten feature would that be?
Flash support?, Multitasking?, or the few others that have just slipped my memory

01 February 2010, 10:36 AM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Phred (User):

Quoting apt.pupil:
For almost half the price of a Mac i could happily build a pc/linux computer with at least 30% more "umph"

Whilst I agree with you, the hardware is more expensive and their upgrade cycle is a little crazy, than say your DIY 'Yum Cha' box, but what Apple offers, is an experience that "just works" out of the box, and this is what mums & dads want without the messing around with Linux and Windows.

And this is something that the broader IT Community appears to forget.

01 February 2010, 12:29 PM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

apt.pupil (Cornerstone member):

Quoting Phred:
Whilst I agree with you, the hardware is more expensive and their upgrade cycle is a little crazy, than say your DIY 'Yum Cha' box, but what Apple offers, is an experience that "just works" out of the box.

Mums and dads would also want to run software they are familiar with. Sadly for those who have not been there since Macintosh had a GUI, and moved up through the ages- they can often find some issues with running windows programs, and even boot camp dpes not properly run all windows software.


Quoting Phred:
And this is something that the broader IT Community appears to forget.


Sometimes it is not just the "out of the box working" that matters. For example- one reason why i will never permanantly stick with Linux OSes is because it either does not run my windows software at all, or runs it with strict limitations. Half my software that i run would be useless on a mac, and i don't want to pay any more than is necessary.


While i give credit to the quality of mac builds, in my honest opinion- a pc that is built and set up by hand, and not off a process line has a certain personality to it. if you buiolt it yourself, it has a part of you with it. If someone else built it(and professionals DO warrant their customs) to meet your own personal needs, it is just as likely to "work out of the box" like a mac


01 February 2010, 4:13 PM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tin (Cornerstone member):

Quoting Phred:
what Apple offers, is an experience that "just works" out of the box,


Apart from the exact same levels of confusion when it comes to internet access, new and different interface, finding software that does what they want, etc....

Reality is that Apple offers nothing more than a shinier version of everyone else's home user products. They're fine as far as loading a few programs already installed, fiddling with them, and turning the computer off. But come anything technical, it doesn't matter what OS it is because they won't be able to do it easily.

01 February 2010, 7:43 PM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Phred (User):

Quoting apt.pupil:
Flash support?

Flash support is at best patchy in Linux, with it still pushing Linux to it's limit.


Quoting apt.pupil:
Multitasking?

The iPod, iPhone, iTouch and now the iPad are designed to do one thing really well, and they're not computers. If you want a computer, buy a laptop/netbook.

01 February 2010, 12:32 PM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

apt.pupil (Cornerstone member):

Quoting Phred:
Flash support is at best patchy in Linux, with it still pushing Linux to it's limit.

say what? i have never had Flash issues on a linux distro in the entire time i have been using them. Program compatibility and end- user smugness, yes- but flash has not once been an issue

02 February 2010, 12:18 AM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

agami (User):

Sting?
I've got 3 Prepaid Broadband I use with my netbook and I pay $29.00 for 2 GB. It's not unlimited but most months I don't even consume all of it.

02 February 2010, 12:45 AM (6 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Raindog (Cornerstone member):

Quoting agami:
It's not unlimited but most months I don't even consume all of it.

So that must apply for everyone then? Many will chew through 2Gb in days, so what works for Eddie probably will not be the ducks guts for others.

There is probably not too much about these plans that's more or less deceptive than the over-all poor value offered by most Australian consumer level data plans. Certainly none of the shockers like some that emerged within the release frenzy of iPhone.

The real question people need to ask themselves is, even at a mere $29 a month what is their thirty bucks or more actually buying them in in iSlab form?

Given the almost absent connectivity or interoperability of the iSlab you'd be hard pressed to do anything that's actually useful with one.

So that's $3600pa or more plus $700 minimum, that people are going to shell out to relieve those moments of lunchtime or bus stop boredom. Value plus for the salary slaves but hey what value can be put on the idea that people you don't know can be thinking hey that geek has an ISlab.

02 February 2010, 7:25 AM (5 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags