Leopard giveth, and Leopard taketh away...

David Flynn
06 November 2007, 12:29 PM


Can't get your Address Book to talk to your Bluetooth phone? That's just one of Leopard's missing features which are now starting to come to light. Plus, why some Mac software developers refuse to take the heat for Leopard incompatibility.


Steve Jobs crowed that Leopard had over 300 new features. Scores of ‘Mac journalists', that peculiar breed of largely sycophantic scribes, faithfully spun the same line. But neither Jobs nor his little winged monkeys mentioned the stuff that Apple took out of its shiny new OS.

Yet as the first wave of upgraders settle in and poke around Leopard's every nook and cranny, they're realising that some features of Tiger and earlier editions of OS X have gone MIA.

Little things like being able to use Bluetooth to dial your mobile and send SMS messages from the Address Book, and then to read and reply to incoming SMS messages on your Mac.

Bye-bye, Bluetooth: Leopard's Address Book no longer lets you use a Bluetooth link to your mobile phone to dial numbers or send, receive and reply to SMS messages Bye-bye, Bluetooth: Leopard's Address Book no longer lets you use a Bluetooth link to your mobile phone to dial numbers or send, receive and reply to SMS messages
Sorry, did we say 'little'? For notebook fans and road warriors, this is a jaw-dropping downgrade. An incredibly handy trick, which exemplifies the Mac's smart and seamless ‘it just works' philosophy, thoughtlessly ripped out and sacrificed for a dollop of eye candy. In other words, a real pisser. Yet Leopard's Address Book (which is earmarked as version 4.1) completely nukes those Bluetooth-linked call and SMS functions.

Quick fix: the EmitSMS widget brings back Bluetooth dialling and SMSing from your Mac notebookQuick fix: the EmitSMS widget brings back Bluetooth dialling and SMSing from your Mac notebook
We don't know why, but we know what you can do about it: grab EmitSMS 1.85 (aka, The Program Formerly Known as SendSMS). This free widget works with any Bluetooth phone, says the author, even models not directly supported by the Address Book. It also has an Address Book look-up of names, splits messages longer than 160 characters into multiple SMS messages and advise that your SSM was successfully sent (which Tiger never did). You can't read incoming SMS messages on your Mac, but that's really a luxury compared to the convenience of composing and sending texts from your Mac's keyboard.


While digging around the Internet for more on this, we stumbled onto the Leopard's Lost Features blog created by ‘Jools' to document and share these head-scratching where-did-it-go moments.

The site also flags that you can no longer put a drive or folder onto the Dock as a convenient shortcut to open that object in a drill-down menu (this action now creates a Stack), and notes that with the Internet Connect application rolled into the revamped Network preferences pane, dial-up modem users (yes, they do still exist) can no longer check and monitor their connection speed.

Meanwhile, the arrival of Leopard was accompanied by scores of software incompatibilities. Danny Gorog has detailed the first batch of fixes as developers rush to tame the tabby, and many Mac fans are pointing out that Apple can't be held to blame for third-party software not being Leopard-friendly. (Which strikes us as funny, in an ironic-rather-than-chucklesome way, because we'd give good odds that they sledged Microsoft for Vista's hiccups with third-party software and drivers. But we digress...)

But developers aren't willing to take all the heat. Steve Gehrman, who created the souped-up Finder replacement known as Path Finder, has shared his experiences and thoughts at the Cocoatech Web site. For starters, Gehrman says the final round of ‘seed' builds were wildly inconsistent in their treatment of third-party software.

"I saw Path Finder bugs appear in one OS seed, disappear in the next couple of seeds, reappear in the fourth one and then disappear again" he recounts. "Unfortunately the last Leopard seed reserved a couple of surprises for us".

Developer Steve Gehrman: bugs would "appear in one OS seed, disappear in the next couple of seeds, reappear in the fourth one and then disappear again"Developer Steve Gehrman: bugs would "appear in one OS seed, disappear in the next couple of seeds, reappear in the fourth one and then disappear again"
Another developer commenting in Gehrman's blog supported this. "In my Leopard testing I observed our software bugs appear, dissapear and reappear again across Leopard seeds" wrote ‘Alexandra'. "We had a couple of issues reappear again on the very last build all of a sudden - they were gone since at least 4 builds or so before. This is very annoying not being able to know if those issues still exist on the final build."

Gehrman also highlights the problem with Apple not giving developers "access to the Leopard Gold Master seed before the general release date", so that they didn't get their paws on the final Leopard code for final compatibility testing until the same time as their customers.

This sentiment was echoed by fellow developer Steven Frank at his blog. "The third-party software that you're paying for, depending on, and hoping to run on Leopard (cannot be tested) on the final release build until we can run down to the Apple Store and pick it up, hopefully at least a few minutes before you do."

"This isn't a new thing" Frank admits. "It was the same deal with Tiger, and other OS releases before it. Apple has not stated any reason why the final builds are withheld from developers. There has been speculation that it's to prevent pre-release piracy of the OS, but that argument doesn't hold much water -- in the best possible case, they are simply delaying piracy by about a week. The more likely scenario is that the final build will appear on BitTorrent trackers before it appears on store shelves despite this quaint measure."

 


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

sandra_madness:

Short Memories, Short Sighted - Many comparisons can be made to problems with Vista here. In fact so too with Windows 95, 98 and XP, not to mention others. Incompatability issues are the norm when new OS's are released. I clearly remember the talk 6 years ago when XP arrived and it is so familiar to talk today, yet I noticed that all the XP knockers I heard, ended up using it. So too I was reading some old magazines last night, and the same issues were thrown up against Win98 over Win95.
New OS's bring new challenges, I myself face a challenge with a number of copies of Adobe Acrobat 7 that are only a couple of years old yet very powerful and more than ample for my business yet incompatable with Vista or Leopard. Same is said for my accounting software, only a few years old. To solve, they are installed on virtual machines. The big point for me is not the OS's, as upgrade and OEM versions are cheap for what they are, I would not begrudge MS a few hundred dollars for what you get for your money. For me it is the software companies that charge big dollars for the software they produce. The sheer cost of upgrading my software prohibits my business from upgrading all systems to Vista & Leopard not the OS's themselves.

The moral for me is that the WIN/MAC/LINUX bagging needs to stop and the energy instead focused on companies that refuse to provide support and upgrades for products that in some cases are only relatively new.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

asus:

The best application for using the bluetooth features of mobile phones on OSX is far and away BluePhoneElite. http://mirasoftware.com/BPE2/

It does way more than the Address Book did anyways.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Lapfrog69:

I am using BluephoneElite now it is V2 iteration to send, receive sms, store and manage sms with several phones at once, also initiate and get information about callers on screen. Very compelling. Much better than Address book previous bluetooth features.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

mrsteveman1:

I say this as someone who has bought Apple products in the past, but Apple needs to drop the flaky behavior. As an example, Apple and their employees take the position that they are in complete control of the platform, regardless of what users want, and this is why you have features being completely removed, because Apple said so.

The issue of pre-release testing is also ridiculous and highlights the fact that Apple has a long way to go before they are able to support an entire ecosystem the way Microsoft does. In the Apple world, no one, anywhere, can see an Apple product before its release date, even if it means stuff crashing because you locked out your own developers.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Matt:

This must be a faked article. Macs just work. They don't have compatibility problems, and they have 300 NEW FEATURES. There's no way any of this could be real. Lalalalalalalalalala

- Annoying Vocal (not average) Maccers That I Have to Work With

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

DanielEran:

I'm aware of some changes in Leopard that drop features, such as the fact that the new Front Row no longer uses iTunes internally, so the new version can't currently do AirTunes (you have to use iTunes to play out music to an AirPort Express).

However, trying to sensationalize the missing ability to dial your mobile phone via Bluetooth makes you sound really desperate. Was that really the best example you could scrape together?



29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Dave Flory:

"The site also flags that you can no longer put a drive or folder onto the Dock as a convenient shortcut to open that object in a drill-down menu (this action now creates a Stack), "

Did you just quote the other site without even checking this?

You _can_ put folders on the dock and it _does_ make a stack, but any stack icon can be 'drilled into' my merely holding down the mouse button for a second instead of clicking, or by right clicking on two button mouse, or by Control-Clicking, not too difficult an action for any of them.

This opens the folder in a window allowing all standard Finder actions.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

David Johnston:

Bluetooth from Address Book was there in the development seeds, but was too buggy to include in the final release. The school of thought is that it will be back in 10.5.1.

Something else that is missing is fullscreen mode in X11. This means that you can no longer use you mac to log into a Unix workstation using XDMCP. The programmers were only part way through switching X11 from xfree to xorg when the OS went gold master. Although one nice improvement is that if your forward an application's gui to your mac using aqua's terminal, X11 automatically starts up.

These are just two examples highlighting the fact that Leopard just wasn't finished at it's time of release.

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Kelvin:

There appears to be website rendering problems with Leopard which weren't present in Tiger. The Mozilla web site admits there are problems with drop-down menus (amongst other things) in Firefox 2.0.0.9, and a good example would be the Commonwealth Bank NetBank site. Although this isn't the most browser-friendly site (especially after the 'upgrade'), it worked fine in Safari and Firefox in Tiger. Try loading it in Leopard with Safari, Firefox, or Camino and you'll get some bizarre errors.

On the other hand, Safari 3 seems to have corrected some Javascript errors which were present in the old version. It seems like a case of give and take!

29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (3 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user