IN DEPTH REVIEW: Motorola Milestone - the Droid we've been waiting for?

Neerav Bhatt27 December 2009, 2:54 PM

The marketing tagline for this blockbuster Android phone is "Droid Does, iDont" -- squarely mocking the iPhone. So does it live up to expectations?

Page 1 - Intro

This aggressive attack on the Apple iPhone's shortcomings resulted in Motorola selling as many as 800,000 Droid handsets in the first week of US sales, according to one analyst's estimates, and they've followed on by launching a direct to retail GSM version of Droid in Europe branded as the Motorola Milestone.

The following review is based on this European Milestone 3G HSDPA version of the phone which will work with all Australian mobile frequencies except Telstra's NextG. Motorola Australia wouldn't tell us if or when it would be released in Australia, but it's a pretty sure bet it will be coming soon, given how dire Motorola's situation is in the mobile handset market -- it will want to get this product out to as many markets as possible to reinvigorate its ailing brand reputation.

As an interesting side note, Verizon/Motorola had to pay a licence fee to sell the phone as "Droid" in the USA because DROID is a registered trademark of Lucasfilm.

Much to the dismay of Australian Star Wars and Android fans, the high cost of licensing the name means it is unlikely a similar phone released in Australia will bear the Droid name.

Motorola's big bet on Android

Motorola, the company that invented mobile phones, hasn't released a cool new phone for so long that many people will have just about forgotten they still have a mobile division.

The Motorola logo displayed on screen when the Milestone is powered on is reminiscent of the Bat Sign displayed in the sky by Gotham City to signal an emergency that requires Batman's help. We're sure this similarity was unintended, but it reminded APC that this is probably the last roll of the dice for Motorola's stale mobile division.

Once the market leader with its RAZR phones, Motorola realised it had been usurped by the iPhone, Blackberry and other cool new smartphones, and decided to make a big bet on Android in 2008, dedicating hundreds of developers and a substantial financial investment in the hope that hitching its wagon to the nascent open source Google Android mobile operating system would be successful.

So is this the Droid you've been looking for? Keep reading our in-depth review to find out if this rebel alliance of Motorola and Google's Android 2.0 operating system will cause people to hesitate when they consider buying an iPhone.

Continue to page 2: Setting up Droid
Page 1 Intro
Page 2 Setting up Droid
Page 3 Droid's AMAZING screen
Page 4 What's in the new Android 2.0
Page 5 Shortcomings
Page 6 Battery life and apps compared to the iPhone
Page 7 APC's Verdict
Page 8 Buying the Motorola Milestone/Droid in Australia


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Dan Warne (Administrator):

Can't wait to try this one out... the fast processor coupled with better OS sounds very interesting. Not sure about the sideways QWERTY keyboard though - I'm more of a fan of a Blackberry style keyboard.

28 December 2009, 4:43 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Neerav Bhatt (New user):

FYI Motorola confirmed at CES that all their Android Devices will be updated to 2.1 (Eclair). Also, Flash 10.1 will soon be on it's way for the Droid

10 January 2010, 1:33 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Neerav Bhatt (New user):

I'm already running 3rd party firmware with Android 2.0 on my HTC Dream and it rocks :)

28 December 2009, 6:19 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply
28 December 2009, 10:25 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

josh098 (New user):

"It should be noted that the ratio of free/paid apps is inverted when comparing the Android Market (62% free apps) to the Apple iPhone Store (23% free apps) so Android users have a lot more apps available to use for free."

the iPhones app store has over 100,000 aps (23,000+ free apps)
the android store has 20,00 aps (12,400+ free apps)

*"so android owners have" less than half the apps available to use for free*




28 December 2009, 11:49 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

apt.pupil (Advanced member):

Quoting josh098:
"It should be noted that the ratio of free/paid apps is inverted when comparing the Android Market (62% free apps) to the Apple iPhone Store (23% free apps) so Android users have a lot more apps available to use for free."

the iPhones app store has over 100,000 aps (23,000+ free apps)
the android store has 20,00 aps (12,400+ free apps)

*"so android owners have" less than half the apps available to use for free*

don't sound so smug there buddy.
they were not comapring the number of apps, but rather the ratio of free to paid apps.

by the way- i am not an android owner- and it will take a simply mindblowing phone to make me convert- but on the other hand- you will NEVER- i mean NEVER get me to own an iphone.

i much prefer the completely open source windows mobile.

if we are atalking apps- wise- microsoft has clocked over 80,000 official apps, but i can tell you first hand that there is way more than that available if you know where to look. what makes me stick with winmo is the complete windows compatibility: the faster file transfers, microsoft office mobile, the full .zip extenstion supprt, and many many more little extra benefits.

when the HTC Touch HD2 arrives in Australia- it will own what android has to offer- though it will be at a price


29 December 2009, 11:30 AM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

josh098 (New user):

"It should be noted that the ratio of free/paid apps is inverted when comparing the Android Market (62% free apps) to the Apple iPhone Store (23% free apps) so Android users have a lot more apps available to use for free."

iPhone app store 100,000+ Free apps: 23,000+
Android store 20,000+ 12,000+

*"so Android users have" have half the amount of free apps available to them*

:S

28 December 2009, 11:49 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Eruaran (New user):

This I think is a reasonable prediction: It won't be too long before Android market is bigger than Apple's app store. Developers like Android and see an exciting and fast growing market. Furthermore, there's no 'walled garden' controlled by a very capricious corporation that can set developers back months.

29 December 2009, 1:32 AM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply
09 January 2010, 6:10 AM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Gyansta (New user):

I got the motorola droid/Milestone GSM Unlock version and its show only Egde for my internet connection. I'm wondering whats up with that. Isn't suppose to be 3G? Maybe it's something I'm not doing.

10 January 2010, 1:21 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Neerav Bhatt (New user):

Maybe there's no 3G mobile tower in your area?

Otherwise you might not have the proper APN setup? see http://sholes.id.au/apns/

10 January 2010, 1:30 PM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Gyansta (New user):

I figured it out. The Milestone version does not support 3g in the US. man I returned it immediately when I saw that.(I never saw that section of the compatibility area). I'm moving on to the Nexus One(Google phone). I'm expecting to have today. Can't wait for FedEx to knock on my door.

14 January 2010, 4:57 AM (2 months ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags