Plasma vs LCD - which is best?

Tony Sarno
09 August 2007, 9:29 AM


Games and high def movie downloads look great on HDTVs, but before you even walk into the shop, you'll have to choose between plasma and LCD. We've looked at the latest TVs in both technologies to make the decision easier for you.


 : HDTVs in the APC Labs : HDTVs in the APC Labs

So you want to get high definition TV at home? Forget about the battle over Blu-ray vs HD DVD -- the first decision you're going to have to make is whether to go with plasma or LCD.

There are many claims and counterclaims about the merits of each, so we decided to test out a selection of the latest plasma and LCD sets from companies such as Toshiba, Sony, Panasonic, Samsung, LG, Philips, Grundig and Pioneer.

APC staff assessed the TVs over two weeks. Our challenge was to find objective tests that would settle the plasma vs LCD question once and for all.

While PCs can be tested against objective benchmarks, we found that a HDTV's picture is the result of a number of factors: the size and native resolution of the TV set, the resolution of the source content, and the effects of various picture-processing technologies adopted by individual TV makers. And of course, the eye of the viewer. So the testing involved a lot of staring at screens playing different types of content in a variety of lighting conditions.

In this month's APC magazine, we've published our verdict on where each technology works best. But on apcmag.com, we'll put the case for each and let you, the readers, come up with the verdict.

If you have a plasma or LCD HDTV tell us of your experience with its performance in the comments at the bottom of the Case for Plasma or the Case for LCD.

The faceoff

PAGE 1/5. NEXT PAGE >>

COMING UP IN OUR HDTV SPECIAL


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Ican Tok:

When do we get to see your reviews on the individual screens, I'm buying this week and waited over the weekend to see where you fell on a couple of machines I'm considering...got a date and time for us?

29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tony Sarno:

Hi, a couple of the vendors have just released new HDTV sets which we would like to include - so for the individual reviews we're removing some older sets used in our plasma vs LCD comparison and replacing them with new ones to give readers a more up-to-date roundup. LG's new LCD HDTV came in to our Labs yesterday, so we'll need a couple of days to give it a good working over. Their older LCD wasn't too bad, so we're really looking forward to testing the new one. However, if you need some advice right now, in summary, if you want a plasma, we were impressed with the Panasonic Viera (we looked at the 50in TH-50PX70A model), and if you want an LCD, the new Toshiba Regzas (we tested the 32WL68A 32in panel, but look at the C3000A and WLT66A model ranges for TVs with integrated tuners) are the state-of-the-art in LCD HDTVs. In terms of picture-quality, the Toshiba was neck and neck with the Samsung 40in LA40M8.

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Ican Tok:

Very Helful, many thanks. I had already narrowed it down to the 50" Panasonic Viera 50PX70A up against the Samsung 50" PS50Q9HD or the Samsung LCD LA40M8. Will wait for the detail in your reviews now in any case while I take a look at the Toshibas. Keep up the good, and in my case, very timely, work. More power to you and APC Mag.

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Bill:

Just hang out till Laser arrives....

29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Zander:

or you could hang out till the technology AFTER laser arrives...or the technology after that. But then of course you'll be waiting for a couple of decades.

Don't wait around for the 'next new thing' or you'll never get to enjoy anything. Plasma and LCD are where it's at now, so go for it! :)

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Jewel Boot:

Plasma and LCD will be made obsolete within a couple of years by Sony's new OLED displays. I saw some at the recent Sony exhibition in Sydney and they blew me away. They have massive contrast ratios and a response time of 0.01 ms - vs 6ms on the best LCD screens or 4ms on plasmas. Only problem is it will probably be a couple of years before they are sold as HDTVs. BTW I don't work for Sony.

29 February 2008, 8:31 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Sinclair:

found this on Sony's site about OLED: "OLED works with self-luminous organic materials, it has outstanding response time, without producing any afterimage even when displaying moving images..." Luminous organic materials?? OMG - it's made of glowing vegetables sandwiched between two glass layers. Hate to see what lifespan it'll have. It will make plasmas look long-lived.

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

HL of S:

How do you know it's vegetables? Could be animal but then we would have to call RSPCA (cruelty to animals in OZ)

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Tim Polmear:

C'mon now. The technology used to run your TV has only a minimal effect on the size of your ePenis. Heck there are folks out there still watching CRTs (woodja bleeb dat?)
Obsolete or not, LCDs and Plasmas are still going to be perfectly watchable, because after all, TV isn't mission-critical.

I haven't seen the review, but perhaps APC might have done well to rate the different sets according to energy efficiency, standby and peak current consumption, heat output, TCO, end-of-life provisions and so on. Damn, I almost sound like some tree huggin' nut.

29 February 2008, 8:47 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Anonymous56473829:

the new lazer system succeeds them all
unfortunately it is not allowed to hit the market



29 February 2008, 8:32 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

blow in:

Could be true, look at the electric car etc - commercial viability and roadmapping will continue at the expense of the consumer!

29 February 2008, 8:48 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Fred:

The term "laser" is an acronym for "Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation". Not 'Ztimulated'... don't know what 'lazer' is an acronym for.



29 February 2008, 8:48 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Kaz:

yeah wow he misspelt it!

29 February 2008, 8:50 PM (4 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user