Powerline 200Mb/s hits Australia

Nathan Davis07 February 2007, 9:53 PM

Netgear has finally launched the 200Mb/s Ethernet-over-mains power adaptor in Australia. As convenient as they may be, however, there is an ugly catch.


Netgear's HDX101: Packed with an electrifying warranty.Netgear's HDX101: Packed with an electrifying warranty.
Netgear has released its 200Mb/s mains power networking adaptors in Australia -- quite unexpectedly, we must admit.

Several months ago we asked a Netgear spokeswoman if it was about to release an Aussie 200Mb/s edition, as it had just surfaced in the UK. "NETGEAR does not have plans to release the HDX101 in Australia," I was told.

Apparently Netgear changed its mind -- either that, or it was doing subtle misdirection in an attempt to keep the competitors at bay.

In terms of features, it says "Configurable QoS is ... accessible to advanced users and encrypted security protects the network from hackers." Netgear doesn't mention what form of encryption this is, however you will require either Windows 2000 or XP "to modify encryption and settings."

Each adaptor, dubbed a 'HDX101 Powerline HD 200Mbps Ethernet Adapter,' will set you back a hefty $229. Alternatively, the 'HDXB101 Powerline HD 200Mbps Ethernet Adapter Kit,' which is a collection of two adaptors, will demand $429, docking $14.50 from each.

Considering their somewhat high-voltage design, the warranty deserves some attention. Netgear recommends you plug the adaptors directly into the wall for best performance. This sorta kills off surge protectors.

What happens if your network adaptors are damaged through a power surge (including the ones in your computers, consoles, etc.)?

Netgear's response to APC didn't exactly allay our concerns: "Any damage resulting from an event like this would be the customer’s responsibility."

Certainly something to keep in mind.

Netgear says the adaptors can transmit "a fast and stable network connection into corners Ethernet cabling won’t reach."

Reach isn't really the issue here, but convenience certainly is, as it beats hanging cable all around the place. Well, unless you're crazy enough to not mind that sort of thing. Hello.

Don't roll up and toss out the good stuff just yet, though. The inherent problem with mains power-based networking gear is the separate circuits of your house.

Naturally, jumping from one circuit to another isn't going to happen. This is why, when you turn on that blasted faulty toaster, the entire kitchen might go out, but the lounge is still fully juiced.

Unless you're quite familiar with the layout of your home's circuits, in order to check for accessibility, it's really just a matter of plugging in these units and hoping for the best. You could treat it like an expensive lucky draw.

Or, and this is probably a better method, you could turn off the circuits at the mains box one by one and discover how the circuits are arranged. We'd suggest you do this before buying these adaptors and getting all miffed because the toilet is on a different circuit to your bedroom.

Interestingly, these units won't actually connect at 200Mb/s. Each adaptor features a single 10/100Mb/s Ethernet port, which is undoubtedly a slight setback.

If you bought into Netgear's previous line of mains power networking gear, the 85Mb/s ones, unfortunately this flash new beast won't so much as peep at them -- the adaptors need to be the same type to make a connection.

This might be worth having a look at if you're after the speed of Ethernet without the mess. Mind that nasty warranty, though.


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Rob:

Why bother playing with 240V peripherals? Why not just use wireless? These days wireless is getting better and better, not to mention cheaper.

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

APC administrator:

Powerline is usually of interest to people for whom wireless isn't an option... there are some buildings that are surprisingly bad for it.


29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

justthething84:

Please wireless is no where near as good as what network products companies make it out to be. Ive got an N1 Wireless router and a 2 story brick home. It does reach upstairs but drop outs are so common its not funny.

On the back of the packages of these wifi routers shows diagrams of huge coverage such as a coverage sphere around a 2 story home with a large tree in the backyard showing the sphere covering beyond the tree. Well wifi just doesnt seem to cut it yet. Even if wifi gets better im concerned that it could cause cancer - who knows what it does as it has only been out for a short time. We all know the stories behind mobile towers - yeah they are much more powerful than wifi adapters but even so i would like to limit any chance of getting cancer (if they pose a problem).

As for this powerline networking device - this is the best product i have seen in years. The only problem with them is that (as mentioned) if you have a few different circuits in your home you may be screwed. I know we have different switches on our powerbox for lights, garage, oven, laundry, east side and west side (of house) so who knows maybe I wont be so lucky.


Bring on the Internet through our community powerlines and piss telstra off for GOOD!

29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

camandco1:

In complete agreement.

My room is right up the top, right at the back of the house, and the wireless router is downstairs, in the middle office, through about 10 metres of concrete and bricks. Hence i get a connection dropout at least twice a day, and it takes yonks to "aquire network address" when i log on.

The netgear powerline adaptor is faster than my wireless (and im using it for internet only so no need for 200mb/s coz no internet that fast), and quicker to connect.

The only problem i had was when i discovered half my room is on a different circuit to the other half, because they ran out of space to run "wires" up. So i run an extension cable out of a working powerplug in my closet. And despite the fact that this is not recommended, i still get fast enough speeds. Although i dont think i could stream with it.

29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

raindog:

If you could run an extension lead why didn't you run a Cat5 cable? Would have been a cheaper solution.

Power-line adaptors do not need to be on the same circuit to work but the must be on the same electrical phase. That said all the same rules of attenuation apply and you are likely to get poor or no connection between the ends of long power circuits.


29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Heloc23erdc:

9: AT LEAST ITS HIGH SPEED
CHILLOUT GUYS AT LEAST WHAT YOULL GET AFTER THE SPENDING IS PREETY HIGH ,GRRSUPER HIGH SPEED INTERNET I WISH I WAS IN OZ THAN ID HAVE SUPER FAST NET TOO DAMN MY ISP SUCKS WWW.CONET.COM.FJ((REALLY)) SLOW WITH MANY PROBLEMS BE GR8FULL WITH WHAT YOU HAVE


29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

BrandonWayne-homeplug:

Wireless still has issues with drop outs and security still seems to be of main concern.The reality for homeplug is that in the US they are looking to homeplug technology in some cases to replace wireless and work along side it.It makes perfect sense especially in Australia where Telstra infact cripples our broadband that basic untilities like the Power Grid systems can infact bring broadband at adsl2 and greater speeds using the existing wiring infrastructure instead of the (case of WA Western Power) trying to roll out fibre optic to suburbs which everyone knows means the CBD first the rest of the suburbs could wait upto 10 years for roll out.
Homeplug technology with uses of satellite,wireless and fibreoptic as the back bone can roll broadband out to houses,hotels and businesses using the existing wiring infrastructure at far greater speed of implemenation than roll out of fibre optic cable to the suburbs.
This if power utility(as in case of tasmania which is using this technology in parts of trial *footnote they appear to use software version of homeplug to achieve greater speeds which is prone to drop outs)would mean we could truly have second main internet provider to rival telstra of or internet providers.

29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

James Bannan:

I bought a couple of the 85Mb/s units a while back to connect upstairs to downstairs, and to be honest as long as you don't have too much attenuation between the points the speeds are fine for pretty much anything you want to do.

 I've got one of the units plugged into a power board (and it works fine) and I'm getting 50-60Mb/s between the two.  More than adequate for surfing or uPnP streaming, and file copy is pretty good also.  The only area where it causes bottlenecking is transferring very large files (500MB+) as this takes up the whole pipe and causes a slowdown.  But for everything else 85Mb/s is till totally fine.



29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

tin:

$230 buys a lot of Cat5. And almost as much Cat6. And then you have to double it to be any use. At that price, you may aswell get the place properly cabled by a licensed installer.

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

raindog:

$230 doesn't buy much in the way of installation or specialist wall finishes though.
Even at trade prices add the cost of cable wall plates, fixings and redo the sums for providing a data connection point. Add labour and that $230 figure is not in the hunt.
Power line devices like this can serve as good niche solutions when you need to get data out to the marble reception desk in the foyer of a heritage building or other similar situations. And not everyone in a rental property wants the Cat5 cable gaffa taped down the hallway. (though surprisingly many are almost proud of such handy-work)
The price of these devices is exxy and the performance limited or variable but whilst not replacing dedicated wiring solutions, using this type of device is still worthwhile in some circumstances.

29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Heloc23erdc:

you complain alot

29 February 2008, 8:37 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

PRILVESH:

CHILLOUT GUYS AT LEAST WHAT YOULL GET AFTER THE SPENDING IS PREETY HIGH ,GRRSUPER HIGH SPEED INTERNET I WISH I WAS IN OZ THAN ID HAVE SUPER FAST NET TOO DAMN MY ISP SUCKS WWW.CONET.COM.FJ((REALLY)) SLOW WITH MANY PROBLEMS BE GR8FULL WITH WHAT YOU HAVE

29 February 2008, 8:30 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Jacob Smith:

What? Do you actually know what you are talking about? Sure, the adapter can handle 200Mbits, doesn't have any thing too do with our internet speed.

IIRC, the fastest we can get is 24Mbits. So, that's JUST under 10 times the speed the Power Network adapter can get. The 24Mbit connections are pretty much pointless because we are stuck with download limits that could be went over in a week. Oh, and ADSL2 isn't even available to over 50% of the country(Last time I checked anyway). In fact, where I live only just got ADSL1 last November. And I still know places that can't get it just because Telstra doesn't see it as a profit making area for ADSL.

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

brandonwayne-homeplug:

Whilst the 200 Meg sounds good the software type versions only give you at best 14m on the other hand the 200M in standard house gives you at best approx 85M at worst 54M.This is that semi fictious speeds they give or sizes of memory.This is same as wireless 54m luck to get 10m.

But still if homeplug was used by utilities like the power grids we would have success at adsl at greater speeds

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Heloc23erdc:

Vista is good you all suk

29 February 2008, 8:30 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

raindog:

Heloc the people of Earth wish you well on your trip back to your home planet. No matter how bizarre we respect your rights to a point of view.

29 February 2008, 8:40 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags