Price war on LCD monitors: Chi Mei 22" widescreen sells for $509

Sarah Stokely19 September 2006, 5:53 AM

With the arrival in Australia last month of Taiwanese LCD manufacturer Chi Mei, price competition on LCDs has never been fiercer. Chi Mei's 22 inch widescreen monitor is selling for a little as $509.


chimei350.jpg

With the arrival in Australia last month of Taiwanese LCD manufacturer Chi Mei, price competition on LCDs has never been fiercer.

Chi Mei’s 221A 22 inch widescreen monitor, distributed in Australia by Protac, has been advertised for as low as $509 (or $539 with DVI).

It has an impressive 1680x1050 resolution ... higher than many "HD" TVs, and a claimed 5ms response time and 800:1 contrast ratio.

Other brands can cost twice as much for a screen that size, so buyers need to look beyond the price tag to determine what else they may be getting — or missing out on — by choosing on price alone.

I looked closely at Chimei and other manufacturers' pricing to see what bargains are out there and how LCD manufacturers are differentiating themselves when prices are so rock-bottom. (I didn't, on the other hand, look at the monitors themselves from a review perspective, so I'm only talking about pricing alone here without considering the relative quality of the panels.)

In Sydney, Maco Technology had the 221A 22 inch widescreen LCD for $515 (preorder) and the 221D (with DVI) for $570 (preorder).

In Melbourne I found the 221A for $509 or the 221D for $579 at Newcomputers.

dell2407wireless_147x88.gifAnother vendor applying heavy discounts to widescreen LCD monitors at the moment is — no surprises — Dell.

It has an online special of $350 off its2407 WFP 24 inch Ultra Sharp wide screen flat panel, with a bottom-line price of $1299 after the discount. The special ends 21 September, and is limited to three per customer.

"Since the 2407 WFP is so popular with gamers you can currently get it bundled in a multimedia pack with wireless keyboard, mouse and sound bar speakers) for $1299 delivered - a saving of $350," said a Dell spokesperson.

Dell has also lopped $200 off the price of its 2007WFP 20 inch ultra sharp widescreen flat panel, dropping it to $699. The price on this monitor, which features Digital DVI-D (with HDCP) alongside analog, s=video and composite inputs, includes delivery.

viewsonic-vx2025-i1.jpgViewSonic is fighting the competitors' sharp pricing with its own price cuts. It has reduced the price tag on its 20 inch VX2025 widescreen LCD from $589 to $519.

Warranty and dead pixel replacement policies can turn a bargain into a lemon so I asked a few vendors how their offerings stacked up.

Chi Mei’s LCD monitors are sold with a 30 day pixel defect-free guarantee and three year return to base warranty.

Dell offers a 15 day total satisfaction guarantee, which covers the return of the monitor for dead pixels or scratched stand/bezel. Its next-day advanced exchange warranty promises that should you need your monitor replaced, a new one will be dispatched to you the next working day, and the problematic monitor picked up from you. This means no need to return it to point of purchase or send it for checks before getting a replacement.

ViewSonic offers a 30 day zero dead pixel policy to supplement its existing three year limited warranty on LCD monitors.

It's less hassle to known at point of purchase whether your monitor has dead pixels so it can be replaced on the spot rather than having to take a faulty one back to the shop.

This may come down to how helpful the shop assistant (or online retailer) is. In my experience it's worth asking if you can plug in and test the LCD before you take it home.

You can also request this of your online retailer when you place the order - previously I've had good experiences with Eyo when we requested on the purchase order that they plug in and check the unit before shipping.

LINKS


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

barry:

Most LCDs these days don't differ enough to be noticeable by the "average" user. Where the difference lies is in the warranty and how they are setup to back that warranty. Case in point... Twice I have had to use ChiMai monitor warranty, once for a panel that developed a red line and only yesterday one was delivered with dead pixels. In the first instance I shipped the item back to the distributor who replaced the panel with an old one that had burn in on it. Returned again and this time it was fixed but after being messed around to the max. With the new one, I have emailed the distributor 3 times, even including a close up photo of the defect, and also phoned. When I phoned they just said to email the details. Over 30 hours since they were first emailed and not even a confirmation of the contact from them. Warranty is handled by the wholesaler/distributor and not a dedicated agent. The ChiMei monitors are good value, but when it comes to support arrangements to honor their warranty in Australia, it is very poor. Next LCD monitors I buy will have better back up, regardless of cost, I will make sure.

29 February 2008, 8:28 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Pete:

Well I have a Chimei 221D, and its running at max res without any discernable problems. Dead pixels usually show up straight away. As everyone says, the base is crappy, has only tilt, but the panel itself is excellent.

29 February 2008, 8:34 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Steve Allan:

I have had the good fortune to test one of the chi mei,s and the technical specs are excellent
Change the stand ... redesign the bezel and make the whole unit a little more sturdy ( it feels a little plastic ) ... even add $100.00 to the price and nobody will buy anything else ... even as it stands its fantastic value for money and if you look hard can be had even cheaper then you have said

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Luke Evans:

The reason they are so cheap is because they only support 16.7 million colours. Although that is quite a lot it is nowhere near the amount other monitors support. You will be able to tell the difference.

Still good for not gamers and or movie watchers

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Scott:

I have been looking at buying a 221D chimei? given the price I've found they sound unbeatable, But I want one for movies and games, but have heard about this info on them running 16.7m color? So that said what would be a good & closest alternative? Or site that can provide info on such specs?

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Nintek Tully:

You should checkout our Nindeal for Asus 22" LCD @ $569!

http://www.nindeals.com.au/showthread.php?t=2106

29 February 2008, 8:33 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Dorothy:

Luke...use the Farce Luke!

Twenty-four bit color is often referred to as true color because most people have a difficult time distinguishing more gradations than the 16.7 million that 24-bit provides. Many people are unable to distinguish even that many. Even so, many modern graphics cards are now capable of 32-bit color.

Although you might expect 32-bit color to offer an even greater color depth than 24 bit, that's not actually the case. This is because 32-bit color really uses only 24 bits to control the actual colors, so it provides the same range of 16.7 million shades. The remaining 8 bits make up what's known as an alpha channel. The alpha channel is used to control special effects that are often used in gaming, video, and animation.

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Steve:

Absolutely disgraceful Chimei

I purchased a monitor less than a month ago.

I have spent an hour so far on the phone on Saturday

I have spent 1/2 hour today (monday).

My monitor has a dead pixel. I have used it 1 week out of the whole month. (was away).

Now they are refusing to obligate to replace it because its 30 day is "when the sales company" purchased it.

This is disgraceful.. Its is still 30 days before from when i purchased it.

I will keep hassling the supplier of my monitor but WARNING to all who buy Chimei. Lemons.

29 February 2008, 8:29 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags