So you want cheap hi-def movies, eh

Angus Kidman26 February 2007, 10:54 AM

The Australian market's about to get flooded with hi-def DVD players. But where can you get the cheapest movies to play on them?


Let's be honest: whether HD DVD or Blu-ray is your preferred flavour, the market for high definition DVD players isn't yet so huge that the prices for either players or content are likely to drop much.

Last year, a total of around one million players across both formats sold in the US, according to the Consumer Electronics Association.

To put that in perspective, Disney sold five million copies of Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest on DVD in a single day.

Clearly, there's some work to do and, for the moment, a hi-def movie is well and truly a luxury item.

But who says you can't scrabble around and try and get luxury at a discount? (And before someone starts ranting about BitTorrent and muslix64, we're going to stick to legal means here.)

When Blu-ray was officially launched as a format in Australia last week, much was made of the fact that JB Hi-Fi, long a source of discounted stuff on discs, would only be selling Blu-ray titles.

Unfortunately, the current offerings aren't particularly cheap, ranging from $39 to $49 for movie titles.

A search of JB's online store shows that every Blu-ray title in the catalogue is only available on special order. Hold back the crowds!

Remote possibility: Repeatedly pausing your life probably won't make Blu-Ray movies cheaper.Remote possibility: Repeatedly pausing your life probably won't make Blu-Ray movies cheaper.

Other sites do feature lower prices. JB retails the Adam Sandler flick Click! on Blu-ray for $47.99 (plus $2.75 for postage). EzyDVD has it for $42.83 (plus $1.50 for postage), though, like JB, it didn't have any stock when we dropped in.

HD DVD aficionados have one advantage: the lack of region coding means they can roam freely over the Internet and seek out discounts.

Blu-ray fiends will need to stick to the assigned regions, though the fact that this includes Europe makes it more tempting than DVD's more restrictive (albeit easily sidestepped) system.

Shopping around overseas might not help much.

Go ape: If you long for King Kong, can you get it for a song?Go ape: If you long for King Kong, can you get it for a song?

Peter Jackson's King Kong, arguably the most prominent HD DVD-exclusive title, costs $39.83 (plus $1.50) from EzyDVD in Australia.

Amazon sells it for $US34.43, including postage, which comes in at somewhere around $43 Australian.

Auctions don't offer much hope either. Activity in the relevant Australian eBay category isn't exactly vibrant -- there were less than 10 listings when we checked it out -- so bargains may be hard to come by.

The fact that both Blu-ray and HD DVD are dumped in the same category means that you should double-check any listed movie carefully.


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

tin:

I can't see them both taking off. One or the other will, but not both.
And I think a lot of people my age and older will be thinking the same thing and not buying until it's decided. Too many people remember the VHS vs Beta war, and don't want to waste lots of money this time round.

29 February 2008, 8:30 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

J:

It's hard to say whether it will be a beta vs VHS thing all over again as the media can be played in the same machine if the software is set correctly. Samsung has released a hybrid box that plays both. It won't start to pan out until home recorders become more accessible. But then that becomes a moot point when tera byte hd's are becoming more affordable.

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Steve the insensable:

I agree it would seem to be the VHS Beta situation all over again. Which format succeeds will, like before, follow the format that has the largest number of movies, thus market share, regardless of any technical superiority and which one to spend money on, if any, is difficult to predict. The speed with which technology is changing, both may be consigned to pre-history within a few years anyway. Investing in books while they are available may be a better option.

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

justthething84:

The owners of this magazine (the company that owns Channel Nine AND IN COOPERATION WITH MICROSOFT - WHO BACKS HDDVD) are AGAIN dissing bluray (HDDVD's competitor).

HDDVD HAS REGION CODING. This article is incorrect and is just another form of Microsoft trying to destroy competition. APC mag you guys are lame and arent in it for the technology. JBHIFI is ONLY supporting BluRay with makers such as Sony, Samsung, LG, Pioneer, Apple, Warner, Paramount, 20th Century Fox all backing it. The only company making HDDVD players is Toshiba haha when was the last time you saw a Toshiba HiFi component give me a break.

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Richard Olsen:

In response to justthething84, HDDVD does not have region coding yet. There are plans, but nothing has been set. BluRay has always had region coding and no way of sidestepping it. Yet again Sony is shooting itself in the foot for producing something that will no doubt be extremely expensive. (ie Beta, Minidisk, AVCHD etc) I recently purchased a slew of HD DVD movies from Amazon in the US ranging in price from $15USD to $25USD. The key to cheap disc shopping is as usual wait until the specials. The Xbox HDDVD drive retails for $250AUD, due to be released very soon. Cheaper than buying a whole PS3 just for BD and much cheaper than the sony BD drive for desktops topping at over $1000. I think I'll stick with the non Sony product for now and not get caught with another of their propriety wars. I don't really like Microsoft, but I like Sony even less.

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

I love HD:


I have a Hd player and yes APC comments are right about Region coding .Currenty i am playing Region free movies with no problems as well normal dvd and dvd - disks so for best value a hd player for $238 AU is a very good buy . Can blueray do this as well as price The answer is NO .

29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

APC administrator:

I can assure you we have absolutely no interest in pushing one format or another. NineMSN is separate to ACP Magazines Limited which publishes APC -- they just sell the advertising on our site. If you think we're influenced by Microsoft's involvement in NineMSN, check out how many articles we have on the site that are critical of Microsoft.

We're pretty much scratching our heads as much as everyone else trying to figure out which is the better format. They both have their pros and cons. BluRay has superior capacity but seems to be much more expensive; HD is cheaper but may not be the best choice in the long run due to its lower capacity.

It does seem to me that the availability of the cheap HD-DVD drive from Microsoft is the HD-DVD camp's trojan horse. It could end up building a large audience of HD-DVD users long before the PlayStation3 does for BluRay. 



29 February 2008, 8:38 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Robert Vulic:

I think the biggest problem so far with these 2 new formats is.Blu ray has regional coding and HD DVD can only do do 1080 interlace.
How many times has a favorite movie been available in the U.S. on DVD but not in region 4 .It,s pointless bringing a new system half cocked .
As with HD DVD.True high definition is 1080 progressive not interlaced .Why bring a system that give only half the res ?
What the world needs is a only one world system.
Australia is a too smaller market to have a self region.
Then theres the problem of sending family home movies to relations overseas if these formats achieve the level equal to DVD consumer ownership .
Why can,t things be like the film system.
35mm is universal.You can shoot a film on a German camera, edit on a French editor,copy prints on a American optical printer,and then show it in all the worlds cinemas.
Rob Vulic

29 February 2008, 8:30 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

A.nonymous:

Who says 1080p is "True" HD - Sony?
What about the higher resolutions used in digital movie theatres?
And I don't have a 35mm film projector at home, so that's not really a universal option for me...
I agree that there needs to be an accepted HD system, but if the various studios agreed, we wouldn't have this problem...

29 February 2008, 8:40 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user


Tags