The Top 10 Tech Fails of 2011

Staff Writers
21 January 2012, 6:00 AM


Things don't always work out the way you had them planned. Without further ado, here are ten such examples from last year's dishonour roll.




1. HP TouchPad
Sales took off when HP crunched the tablet's price after killing it. With hindsight, now that that the outrage over its termination has died down, we have to say the tablet was good, but not that good. It was too beefy, did not have a 3G option and its awesome battery charger was optional rather than standard with the package. Still, the issues could have been improved in version 2.  

2. HP webOS
Great tablet OS but under previous CEO Leo Apotheker HP no longer wanted to be in tablets (or in most hardware, for that matter). Under new boss Meg Whitman has decided to open source webOS, which is amazing when you consider that HP paid US$1.2 billion for it earlier, when it acquired Palm. Samsung should buy it.

3. BlackBerry crash
Failed RIM router killed internet access for days in Europe, the Middle East and USA. And that was the good news. RIM's share price has collapsed to the point where some of the major shareholders want the blood of the co-founders and co-CEOs, Jim Balsillie and Mike Lazaridis. The only thing which will appease the shareholders appears to be a sale, hence the shopping around of RIM to various potential buyers, from Amazon to Samsung. So what happened? RIM got too cosy in its earlier success selling a communications device to corporations and didn't notice that the iPhone and Android devices were starting to leave its Blackberries behind in several areas, from UIs to app store numbers, and were also encroaching into the enterprise space because those who use an iPhone at home also want to use it at work. 

4. Duke Nukem Forever
Bombed. Crass, filthy and barely playable first-person shooter. Nothing more to be said. Good riddance. A lot of material in gaming these days is crap, but this took tasteless and questionable to new heights. The danger is that it might hang around as a cult game because it's so bad.

5. Google Wave & Buzz
Since these two were shut, Google has closed more services, like its web photo app Piknik. But these aren't fails. They are part of Google's machinery of success. Google succeeds because it’s prepared to try endless numbers of new things and is ruthless about killing them if they don't work.

6. MeeGo OS
Abandoned after appearing on just one smartphone, the Nokia N9. But may resurface as Tizen, a derivative OS which is now rumoured to be back in play in a partnership with Samsung's feature phone OS Bada. 

7. Alienware MX11 laptops
Broken hinges and screens popping marred many of these desirable gaming laptops.
 
8. Final Cut Studio X
Outcry at the radical redesign forced Apple to keep selling previous version, but the new Final Cut Studio X has so angered many videomakers that several are switching platforms, with Avid being one of the main beneficiaries.

9. Dell Streak 5
5in tablet phone never sold like Dell wanted and was killed. Yet the Samsung Galaxy Note, which is getting plenty of acclaim, is pretty similar in concept.

10. Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1
Not a fail per se, but being banned by the courts in Australia for so long took the wind out of its sales (ahem). Its successor will be the one to watch.



Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

petert (Advanced Forumologist):

I would have thought that WP7 should be in the list. To date, it ha been anything but a success. That may change in the future, but so far, and certainly in 2011, it would have to be considered a failure. WP7 was launched with much fanfare - does anyone remember he street parade of a coffin to symbolise the death of all other phone OSes? - but it has failed to achieve expectations. Definitely a failure - at least, so far.

21 January 2012, 8:04 AM (1 month ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

APC Editor (Moderator):

Agree that WP7 is not up there, but when you run it side by side with iOS and Android, it's actually very good, with arguably the most advanced and elegant interface. Sure it doesn't have as many apps as the others, but I would rate its browser and handling of Office docs the best of any smartphone OS. The main problem with WP7 is that Microsoft's marketing of is a big fail. They are just not spending the squillions required to push it to the forefront of consumer consciousness. Microsoft just don't get it, this is not another product like Windows which automatically gets picked up by the market because of the existing installed base. It's a pure consumer play (well, it is if you want massive sales numbers) and they are just not spending enough on marketing it. Where are the nightly TV commercials telling me how awesome the WP7 UI is, or how well it works with your office documents, etc? Where is the Windows Phone 7 -sponsored music festival? It needs to be thrust into the consumer consciousness and Microsoft is not doing that. Is Microsoft doing a Super Bowl commercial on WP7? I doubt it. But we know Samsung is, for its Android phones.

22 January 2012, 6:13 AM (1 month ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

rogue316 (Advanced member):

I'd take the Galaxy Tab over an iPad any day. Love my Flash Player too damned much. lol

22 January 2012, 2:37 AM (1 month ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

ss-rotel (Senior Forumologist):

Duke nukem's more a marketing fail than a tech fail. there's nothing wrong with the game technically, but it should never have been released.

Same with WP7, marketing fail, not technical fail. If MS had pushed the release of the nokia WP7 phones, there'd be a completely different story i'm sure.

i aggree with the galaxy tab. i was lucky enough to have a play with one beside the sony tab s, and even after all the hype the sonys definately the better tab. even thou it's not the most elegant of physical designs, but the interface runs sooo much faster.

Better hardware, or better code optimization it's hard to tell, (i know sony's modifed the OS heavily), but if i needed a tab, id definately buy the sony. hopefully the US price drop spills over into Aust.



22 January 2012, 2:57 PM (1 month ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user