ON TEST: Ubuntu Netbook Edition

Darryl Adams
12 August 2010, 9:30 AM


Yesterday we looked at Jolicloud as an option for netbook owners keen on using the net's cloud computing potential. Today, we look at the big name in Linux: Ubuntu.


The latest version of Ubuntu "Lucid Lynx" -- 10.4 -- comes in a netbook-optimised version that is designed for computer makers to deploy on new netbooks, but it is also available for public download. It's a great operating system choice for netbook users.

One of the more noticeable features of the netbook is the design choices for small screens. It is here that Ubuntu Netbook Edition shines. Using the Gnome Desktop Manager as its base, the user interface is crisp, clean and very functional. The menu system takes the whole left hand side of the screen. Instead of small icons and menu choices like on a normal windows and Linux start menus, Ubuntu Desktop Edition uses big icons that take over the desktop. This is a welcome choice, as it reduces the chance of miss hitting the wrong icon. I quickly found I preferred this system to the normal Gnome/Ubuntu desktop.

Running multiple applications is also well managed. Instead of a paper system, where applications are stacked on top of each other like paper on a desk, Ubuntu Netbook Edition only allows one application to dominate the screen. All running applications are shown as an icon on the top left corner of the desktop (in the traditional spot for the Gnome menus), and clicking the icon swaps the old application off the screen and replaces it with the chosen application. This is an elegant solution, that allows a user to know what programs are running and to swap and change quickly on the fly.

Above: The System Menu for Ubuntu Netbook Edition

While this is a version of Ubuntu optimised for notebooks, it is still Ubuntu. Installation is almost identical to the normal Ubuntu install, and every Ubuntu program available with its software library ( Ubuntu Software Centre) and with the synaptic / apt-get programs, and the most Gnome based programs should install without issue under Ubuntu Netbook Edition.

In its default installation, Ubuntu Netbook Editon actually does more than either Windows or Mac OS X in the same state. You can edit photographs and office documents, use social networks like Twitter and Instant Messaging, play games, videos and music and even allow programming. One of the problems that Ubuntu, and Linux in general compared to Mac and Windows is shipping proprietary software and codes at installation (for example MPEG codecs, programs like Skype and plugins like Flash). Ubuntu will quickly identify when you open a web page or media file and download the required codec/plugin. If there is a Linux version of Acrobat or Skype, it should work inside Ubuntu Netbook Edition, and you can even run some Windows programs under WINE or Virtual Box -- though these two will run very slowly on a netbook.


Above: The Ubuntu Software Centre for Ubuntu Netbook Edition

One thing the Ubuntu has strived with the 10.04 release is better integration with devices. iPhone/iPod interfaces cleanly with the audio program Rhythmbox. Networking by Wi-Fi, 3G and Ethernet is (mostly) built in and Web-cams should also work out of the box, depending on the device (some newer devices, or devices where the manufacturer withholds information about drivers may require further downloads or not work at all, a common Linux issue).

I installed Ubuntu Netbook Edition, and found that after the install and security update, the whole system was a touch under 3GB hard disk space. It also ran reasonably well under 512MB memory. With today's netbooks shipping with 1GB memory, Ubuntu Netbook Editions should run snappily indeed.

 .

Above: The main screen when you start Ubuntu Netbook Edition

One of the strong elements of the whole Ubuntu range in 10.04, and especially useful the netbook variant, is Ubuntu One. This is a cloud based service that allows a shared cloud based storage system, contact syncing with iPhones, Android phones and other computers (via a local program or a web based service), a music store, even shared notes. The service is free with a 2GB file storage limit, or US$10 a month for 50GB -- the same pricing as the popular Dropbox service. The music store is rather weak at the moment, as the curse of music licensing preventing major label music to be available to Australia, but this will hopefully change in the future. If you choose, you can avoid Ubuntu One, as other services like DropBox also work well with Ubuntu Netbook Edition.

Given a 4GB USB key, you could even keep a fully capable cloud based operating system that can be carried in your pocket. You can actually create a bootable USB key using the Startup Disk Creator program that comes installed.

I personally prefer the Netbook Edition over the vanilla Desktop version. The user interface is very intuitive, and the resources footprint is smaller than the normal Ubuntu system. For most netbooks, you will be surprised with the power that Ubuntu Netbook Edition has in a fresh install, and the Ubuntu/Debian software installation system is one of the best on any platform, so installing the software to suit most user needs is rather easy and quick (or even the operating system itself for that matter).


Post your comment



Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Jeff (New user):

"run some Windows programs under WINE or Virtual Box -- though these two will run very slowly on a netbook." -- APC

virtual box yyes, WINE no. Most applications will run with near native speed usign WINE and some applications even run better under WINE than windows! The main question with WINE is whether or not the program will run, though most common applications will run fine.

"some newer devices, or devices where the manufacturer withholds information about drivers may require further downloads or not work at all, a common Linux issue" -- APC

While it can happen, it's rare that you'll actually encounter it these days, in fact I have hardware (a simple external hdd) that won't work under windows (even though it's meant to be plug and play, and yes I have tried on multiple computers with multiple windows versions (XP, Vista and 7)), but has no issues in linux.

12 August 2010, 11:47 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Darryl Adams (New user):

Quoting Jeff:
virtual box yyes, WINE no. Most applications will run with near native speed usign WINE and some applications even run better under WINE than windows! The main question with WINE is whether or not the program will run, though most common applications will run fine.

To a point yes. A small Windows program will run fine with WINE, it really depends on how big the program is. I am not too sure I woudl want to run MS Office in a netbook with WINE....

Quoting Jeff:
While it can happen, it's rare that you'll actually encounter it these days, in fact I have hardware (a simple external hdd) that won't work under windows (even though it's meant to be plug and play, and yes I have tried on multiple computers with multiple windows versions (XP, Vista and 7)), but has no issues in linux

And on the devices. I have had ongoing issues with Linux running devices even today. Vanila Ubuntu 10.4 refused to run with the change of xserver, and I allways have issues with my Belkin Wifi dongle. However, the problems are getting smaller and smaller every release, but as you pointed out, still occur.

Thanks for the feedback Jeff.


12 August 2010, 3:59 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Jeff (New user):

Quoting Darryl Adams:
A small Windows program will run fine with WINE, it really depends on how big the program is.

How big a program isn't the determining factor in how it'll run, though the complexity of such application does make it more likely that there'll be problems. The biggest problem is what system calls the program makes - some areas are know to be inefficient and slow, such as some parts of dirextx, and if calls like this are made then the program can run slowly, but if a lot of these calls aren't made large applications can run without any issues.


Quoting Darryl Adams:
I am not too sure I woudl want to run MS Office in a netbook with WINE...

Office XP at least doesn't have any issue, though I haven't tries any of the later versions - don't actually use office application these days except at work, where I'm stuck with a windows machine.


Quoting Darryl Adams:
and I allways have issues with my Belkin Wifi dongle.

And I always have issues with belkin. fullstop. I have yet to purchase a belkin product that has actually worked (and never will now, since I refuse to buy their stuff now) and I have had several different modems, switches, routers and dongles. Getting a replacement is easy enough, but that doesn't help when all you get is another one that doesn't work. Last item I got was a wireless N router, which I got replaced 3 times, each time it never worked out of the box - I finally got sick of it, got my money back and got myself a linksys.

13 August 2010, 1:53 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

dwr50 (New user):

You failed to say which netbook you used for the article.

13 August 2010, 12:06 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Darryl Adams (New user):

Quoting dwr50:
You failed to say which netbook you used for the article.

For consistancy, I am using Virtual Box virtual machine and 512mb memory. I intend to give quick updates of operating systems when I review netbooks.




13 August 2010, 9:26 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

roszyk (New user):

My Acer Aspire One ZG5 runs the Netbook Remix without any issues. One minor gripe is that the desktop icons are quite large and are not the size cannot be changed (at least not in any way I can find using the GUI). Overall I am pleased with UNR, much better than XP or Windows 7 Starter

13 August 2010, 8:34 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Darryl Adams (New user):

Quoting roszyk:
My Acer Aspire One ZG5 runs the Netbook Remix without any issues. One minor gripe is that the desktop icons are quite large and are not the size cannot be changed (at least not in any way I can find using the GUI). Overall I am pleased with UNR, much better than XP or Windows 7 Starter

I am currently reviewing an ASUS Eee PC, and it comes with Windows 7 Home Premium. Lets just say that any linux netbook distro will runs rings around Win7.




13 August 2010, 9:33 AM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

Fornax (User):

has any one tried running this on a old notebook?

16 August 2010, 5:34 PM (2 years ago)report abuse Send to a friend reply

anonymous user Anonymous user