EeePC 900 with XP
The Eee PC 900 with XP -- fiddy bux cheaper than the Linux version. WTF?

Windows-based EeePC cheaper than Linux one

Send to a friend Print

Help more people find out about this story

Del.icio.us
StumbleUpon

Angus Kidman07 May 20085 days ago.

Is ASUS in bed with Microsoft? The new XP-based EeePC 900 will actually be cheaper than the Linux-based version.

Asus will sell the Windows XP model of its Eee PC 900 for a substantially cheaper price than its Linux counterpart, raising questions about the company's long term commitment to the Linux marketplace.

At a Sydney launch event for the much-anticipated Eee PC 900 model, local product manager Albert Liang revealed that the XP model would sell for $599 in Australia, while the Linux model would be $649. To cover the licence cost associated with Windows XP Home and Microsoft Works — which replace a custom version of the Xandros Linux distribution and OpenOffice — the XP model has just 12GB of storage, while the Linux version has 20GB.

The machines, which sport a wider 8.9 inch screen and weigh in at just under a kilogram, will go on sale in Australia at the end of May. Adding to the impression that Linux is now the poor cousin, the XP version will be sold through "selected retailers" while the Linux machine will be available through "computer resellers". (Translation: No more Linux machines in Myer.)

The original Eee PC, launched in Australia in November last year, has been a major success, selling one million units worldwide. "It has generated a tremendous amount of noise into the market," Liang said.

While the presence of Linux clearly hasn't been a barrier to consumers buying the notebook to date, Asus appears keener to promote the presence of XP on the new range than to expand the Linux market. "Microsoft has been a longstanding supporter of Asus," Liang said.

"People are asking for the familiar and compatible Windows interface that they've used in the past," said Keith Holtham, the account manager for Asus at Microsoft Australia. "The goal was to provide a platform that allows users to have access to their favourite applications."

Holtham made much of the presence of Windows Live applications on the box, including Communicator, Photo Gallery and OneCare Family Safety. He then totally undermined the credibility of the latter by noting that his teenage children seemed able to find anything they wanted online regardless of such filtering software being present.

APC played briefly with the machines on show at the launch. The XP version of the Eee boots quite speedily for a Windows box, but is still notably slower than its Linux counterpart. Even Asus' press release promoting the product acknowledges that the Linux machine is faster to get started. "It provides a fast boot-up time, ideal for quick internet access while waiting for public transport or taking notes on-the-go," it breathlessly proclaims.

Apparently, "the Linux version is suited to users who desire an icon-driven and easy point-and-click interface – well suited for children or users with limited computer experience". We'll leave the reader to deduce what that implies about the XP interface.

Please Digg & Slashdot this story (see box at top of article) to bring attention to this craziness!


Post your comment


Reader Comments

RSS feed Email alert

Spoken4 (New user):

Yes they are. ASUS and Microsoft are firmly married and are promoting a program to get schools to take up the EeePC. I went to a seminar a couple of weeks ago where I almost choked on my MSLatte when the Microsoft rep said "the EeePC is based around hardware standards and we at Microsoft like to think that we are a kind of standard"
MS is desperate to keep schools locked in to their products so students only know one OS and suite of apps.
(Not going to work at mine ;) )

Tin (Regular contributor):

"People are asking for the familiar and compatible Windows interface that they've used in the past"
So Vista and Office 2007 are mistakes then? Or are they just using a variation of the same old "training costs" line without looking on their own desks?

"Holtham made much of the presence of Windows Live applications on the box, including Communicator, Photo Gallery and OneCare Family Safety."
Well that'll encourage me to buy it... I've never heard of any of them. Plus I can only assume they're rubbish if they say "Windows Live" in front of their names.

Reader (New user):

In NZ both models are being sold at Dick Smith, for the same price NZ$749.

kingsmurf (New user):

To the nz reader if you know someone in oz get them to buy it for you & ship it home to you... U'll save $50 on the microsoft version...

prometheus (New user):

I Find it offensive that Asus can claim the license fee for XP is offset by the smaller SSD and then proceed to charge $50 extra for the larger SSD and a free OS!

dv_cool_fuel (New user):

So Microsoft are giving away their obsolete, built in 2001 Operating system with a half baked office suite. And you get less hardware in the bargain. Ill still be buying the Linux version because of the amount of pre installed software that comes with it and the lack of virus/spyware that I wont have to deal with.

dv_cool_fuel

Cod (New user):

You guys are being ripped off. In the UK they are priced exactly the same(£329), with the Linux version having the larger SSD, thus offsetting the M$ tax. They are really good buy the way, virtually everyone in the office has bought the Linux version for the extra disk space.

Here: http://www.eee-900.co.uk/

happy (New user):

@Cod - I think you'll find Pommy buyers are being ripped off, not us Aussies :-) They'll be around AUD82 cheaper here for the XP model.

Live rates at 2008.05.08 16:51:05 UTC
329.00 GBP=681.344 AUD
United Kingdom Pounds Australia Dollars
1 GBP = 2.07095 AUD 1 AUD = 0.482869 GBP




zman (New user):

So the Windows version costs you less dollars? Big deal. What will it cost you in the long run with limited applications and built in adware. How much is it being used as an advertising vehicle to strip more money from the buyer? Microsoft collects from other parties on each unit sold that carries 3rd party "trial software". What limitations do you have to live with using the Microsoft software and OS? How much do you value freedom? Will you be able to freely install the next versions of OS and Apps for free when you go the Microsoft route? --no way.

Just stick with the Linux version. It will do far more out of the box and far more into the future without requiring one additional red cent from the buyer. :) Oh, and you won't have to worry about viruses and what not either. It will actually carry you into the future. Yes, i'll take the extra 8GB for additional $50 knowing that, hopefully anyway, no money will go to Microsoft. :)

Tin (Regular contributor):

Sadly the distro they are using is on the list of distros that have paid the MS ransom... So MS do effectively get money from people buying the Linux version. Given the price cuts on XP to get it onto these type of device, they are probably getting almost as much from the Linux one as they get from the Windows one.
Lame.

John C (New user):

That sucks! I've been hanging out for this model to be released in Australia. Now I have to pay $50 more for the Linux version?!? I'll be demanding the Linux version and make a point of extolling its virtues to the sales-droid.

CB (New user):

I'd encourage everyone reading this who's pissed off about this to make a complaint to the ACCC. I've initiated such a complaint, but there's nothing like a few echoes to make government depts to sit up and listen. This is monopolistic corruption, and it is plainly illegal in Australia.

DenS (New user):

Same goes for NZ; Note: M$ tried their XML patent trick here and failed; this anti-competitive behaviour needs to be brought to the attention of the ComCom here in a well-constructed complaint; time to contact the OSS group here to see whether they will put one together on behalf of the rest of us (their previous connections with Gov have received positive outcomes, and already, some of our MPs already use Linux on their Laptops, it may just put the kybosh on those tactics here).

Sully (New user):

Are you sure what they're doing in Australia is illegal? Personally I don't see how they are violating the Trade Practices Act 1995. However I would find it entertaining and interesting if Microsoft were guilty of an infringement of the TPA.

Raja over all he surveys (New user):

Well that means that the 900 I was going to buy is now off the shopping list. I will not support those who pander to Microsoft and gouge the Linux user. Stuff you ASUS, I will never buy from you again, I'm going somewhere else (yes there are others).

Peter2 (New user):

According to the article Linux version has a lot more memory. And checking pricing from www.asusnotebook.com.au tells me 20Gb 900 Linux costs $649 and XP $799. I'd definitely go for Linux just because of pricing.


ricoch3n (New user):

I would credit the price difference 100% on the SSD size because the combination of evil windoze and totally-idiot M$ works should cost nothing at all.